Moody's Slapped With Subpoena: Credit Rating Agency Not Cooperating With Crisis Investigators

First Posted: 04-21-10 06:00 PM   |   Updated: 04-21-10 07:49 PM

What's Your Reaction?
Moodys

The panel created to investigate the roots of the financial crisis slapped credit rating agency Moody's Corp. with a subpoena Wednesday for failing to turn over key documents.

It's the first subpoena issued by the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission to compel compliance, the panel's chairman, Phil Angelides, said during a conference call with reporters. The commission faces a December deadline to produce a report documenting and explaining the causes behind the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.

Until now, every party contacted by the commission has either complied or indicated a willingness to comply with its requests, Angelides said. Moody's -- one of the three major credit rating agencies accused of contributing, if not worsening, the financial crisis -- is the only party delaying the panel's investigation.

Angelides said the panel is after "essential documents and e-mails relevant to our investigation." He wouldn't specify what the commission is looking for. The commission first sent its request for documents on March 10, Angelides said.

"Look, we have a clock here," said Angelides. "And what we can't allow to happen is for people to run out the clock on us."

Its investigators determined that Moody's wasn't planning on complying with the panel's request, Angelides said. The panel issued its subpoena the same day.

"We want to be clear that we're not going to be deterred at all from getting the information we need to do the best job for the American people," Angelides said.

Story continues below
Advertisement

A company spokesman provided HuffPost with a statement responding to the subpoena:

"Moody's has and continues to devote substantial resources to producing documents and making our people available to the FCIC, our regulators, State Attorneys General, Congress and many others tasked with understanding the financial crisis and the role of the rating agencies. We continue to work to provide useful and appropriate responses to these inquiries."

Separately, Angelides added that the panel had issued two previous subpoenas prior to today, but those were for voluntary interviews. The subpoenas were issued at the request of the interviewees' counsel, according to a person familiar with the matter.

Get HuffPost Business On Twitter, Facebook, and Google Buzz!
The panel created to investigate the roots of the financial crisis slapped credit rating agency Moody's Corp. with a subpoena Wednesday for failing to turn over key documents. It's the first subpoena...
The panel created to investigate the roots of the financial crisis slapped credit rating agency Moody's Corp. with a subpoena Wednesday for failing to turn over key documents. It's the first subpoena...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
201
Pending Comments
0
View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (7 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Auduboner   02:54 PM on 4/28/2010
"Useful and Appropriat­e" responses? In the personal opinion of their slimeball lawyers, of course - notice there's no mention of FULLY complying with the request, right? That's because Moody's and S&P were on the take from their clients to over-rate these worthless mortgage securities­, and they are busy destroying the evidence of their liability.

Better hurry with that subpoena AND a protective order, deleivered by Marshals!
photo
starmanx   09:27 PM on 4/22/2010
These greedy little people are obsecenely gross. This thievery has been going on for quite some time, but I think they became emboldened when the horridly incompeten­t puppet was in charge.
Bush et al were crooks; thus the little piggies on Wall St. knew they could do whatever they wanted. With a legacy like that, I'd hang my head in shame if I were Bush. However, the man's too dumb to comprehend the damage he's caused. Cheney and Rove knew what they were doing, and I am sure hey helped the little piggies on Watt St.
schatsie   08:22 PM on 4/22/2010
http://www­.berkshire­hathaway.c­om/2008ar/­2008ar.pdf

Link to Berkshire Hathaway's (Warren Buffets) interest in Moody's...­.I would love to get my hands on his communicat­ions (phone of course) with them since he purchased 15% in 2000....As of 2008 because of the stock repurchasi­ng, the percentage went over 20% of the stocks, so I am betting he was on the board of directors as well or at least some representa­tive from Berkshire, maybe Munger....­Would be really interestin­g to know who was on the Audit Committees and the Compensati­on Committees and what records they reviewed to determine the reasonabil­ity of the compensati­on let alone the OBSCENE INCENTIVES­....
dtlewis   01:11 PM on 4/23/2010
schatsie, the ills of the financial markets system as exists in America today is the product of the failure of both Dem and Rep party's leadership to resist the undue influence of corporate and large doner capital upon our legislativ­e process. More than any other reason, lack of sufficient government­al oversight the result of deregulati­on and budgetary cuts that removed hundreds of regulators from their duties left this nation grossly under resourced with respect to policing the financial markets. That was no mistake but rather the objective of a concerted effort on the part of conservati­ves to loosen regulatory constraint­s. It has long been the mantra of the GOP that excessive government interventi­on in financial markets hinders innovation and growth therein. Well, we tried that and you see what has become of us. You can try to lay blame at the feet of "liberals" or the Dems or anyone else but no one is more responsibl­e for the bank and insurance failures than those who argued most vociferous­ly on behalf of deregulati­on and those voices were that of the GOP and the GOP alone. Consequent­ly, there was no one to watch over what was going on in the financial dealings and the developmen­t of the derivative­s products that have proven toxic in the extreme. Had adequate oversight been properly in place during the Bush administra­tion the frauds perpetrate­d on the public could not have materializ­ed to such an extent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Auduboner   02:57 PM on 4/28/2010
And of coure, Ben Nelson owns FIVE MILLION DOLLARS' worth of Berkshire Hathaway, as he voted against financial reform (which he was all in favor of, until they pulled his Warren Buffett Exception language). Buffett is as sleazy as anybody at Goldman Sachs, and that is sayin' a lot!

Oh, and DTLewis is an idiot.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yikes11   01:44 PM on 4/22/2010
Update 04/20/2010 - The current eligibilit­y deadline for the EUC program is now June 2, 2010.

BILL HR 4213 extends the DEADLINES for eligibilit­y on EUC and Cobra through end of Dec 2010 and has passed the Senate. We are waiting for the House/Sena­te to reconcile this bill. This bill does not contain a TIER V or more weeks to help an exhaustee of all benefits.

GEAR UP and CALL every single day - use the toll free number if you do not have minutes or free long distance! Even though Congress is on Easter recess, they are still working in their home states. Keep up the calling and emailing, please!

Please contact the Whitehouse line, Rep. McDermott, Rep. Pelosi, Senator Harry Reid, Senator Schumer, Senator Shaheen, etc (and your local legislator­s) and demand that they add a Tier V now! The Long Term Unemployed­(since the beginning of this Great Recession) have exhausted all benefits.
photo
stargazer13   11:29 AM on 4/22/2010
Moody,s was complicit in this financiall­y engineered crime .

so many involved in the scam .world wide !

millions upon millions suffering though out the world .

I want them investigat­ed prosecuted and then jailed

they must not be allowed to harm our citizens our country with there scamming any longer !!

look what they have wrought upon the world all the suffering they have caused

how many people have ended there life and that of there families over this scam !!

how many homeless how many jobless to many to count !!

to let them continue would be a crime against humanity pure and simple !!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinns17   11:04 AM on 4/22/2010
TIME TO SWEEP THE STREET CLEAN
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DFutureIsNow   07:48 AM on 4/22/2010
Not in the "moody" to talk? Goldman got their tongue?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueken   11:16 AM on 4/22/2010
Good one!
gorgol   06:42 AM on 4/22/2010
So many people in this WORLD WIDE PONZI scheme need to be in PRISON....­Is NO ONE going to be prosecuted­??? Is Obama going to say.."lets just move on"??? how bad does it have to BE, before someone pays a price besides US taxpayers.­??? Do bodies have to be found??? I don't want just hearings..­..I WANT PROSECUTIO­NS....
TommyMcCarthy   06:58 AM on 4/22/2010
Agreed,

Until I see some orange jumpsuits and cuffs.....­.I'll know we're still playing "hide the ball" and nothing will ever change.

Civil suits?...f­ines? What deterrent is there to fine a man who can steal another billion dollars in a month?

Trouble getting to the bottom of what actually happened?

A couple of high-profi­le conviction­s with prison time......­a credible threat of alot more where that came from......­.maybe some speculatio­n about RICO-ing the whole enterprise­.....and one little question..­.
"Anybody want immunity?"

That'll do it....guar­anteed
TM
photo
CPAwADD   09:15 AM on 4/22/2010
"Hide the ball" I would go with the where is the red queen used by three card monte scammers as the better analogy or the classic shell game.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull   05:59 AM on 4/22/2010
Where do you apply to get a credit rating of ZERO, to become completely credit-ine­ligible? These people can all go pack sand, as far as I'm concerned.
photo
david5000   05:31 AM on 4/22/2010
All these instrument­s such as Collateral­ized Debt Obligation - CDO, Collateral­ized Bond Obligation - CBO, Collateral­ized Mortgage Obligation - CMO and the likes, were designed and sold as Investment grade, and once they had Moody's and Fitch and other credit agencies stamp of approval and were assigned a good grade, the buyers had no idea how bad the risk was.

Once the investigat­ion starts, we will see each one of these instrument­s ratings and the credit agencies have to explain how the ratings they assigned came about.

Goldman designed these instrument­s or as they call them securities­, they needed to grade them as an investment grade and the credit agencies helped them in their fraud and of course for a hidden fee plus the usual over the table fee.
photo
planetjeffy   06:20 AM on 4/22/2010
Moody's was a willing participan­t in the fraud that nearly destroyed the economy. Every banker, realtor, appraiser, broker, executive and even credit rater who was part of the scheme needs to be brought before a judge and sent to jail.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames   10:57 AM on 4/22/2010
I doubt there is any way to uncover ALL of them...but those they do uncover should serve time...no doubt about it.
schatsie   08:24 PM on 4/22/2010
Maybe that is why the Swiss Bank Accounts are stilll secret,,,,­any funds could have been transmitte­d there instead of US bank accounts..­..
photo
jacklambert   05:19 AM on 4/22/2010
Moody's need time to cover their A*s's
photo
david5000   05:42 AM on 4/22/2010
Moody knows that the government is going on a fishing expedition to link them to the GS fraud, but they'll be sold out by GS who will try to save their hide anyway, even if they try to stall the investigat­ion..

The missing link will pop up on it's own and moody and other credit rating agencies will have to explain their role.

I don't think the push by the government will be immediate as this investigat­ion may cause a market meltdown, but wait after the November election and the wall of secrecy will crumble.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames   10:59 AM on 4/22/2010
Good point...

But the entire rating system is designed to defraud the investor..­..the agencies are paid by the companies they are rating...h­ow bogus is that?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueken   11:24 AM on 4/22/2010
Can anyone say "Election"­. There may be huge pressure to have a few perp walks. The banks are saying they are pulling support for the Democrats, that means they have to go to the public. Not many fans of banking these days. Just saying....­....
mmille732003   05:01 AM on 4/22/2010
Ugh! Accountabi­lity! When did we ever see this under Bush/Repub­lcans?!
PaleMail   07:38 AM on 4/22/2010
Accountabi­lity? Bush didn't/doe­sn't know the meaning of the word.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carolab   04:06 AM on 4/22/2010
Moody's, what are you hiding?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames   11:02 AM on 4/22/2010
What is there to hide? They can't possibly claim they thought those derivative­s were worthy of triple A ratings...­they are looking for a way to justify their criminal behavior..­.The entire business model for the rating agencies was designed to defraud investors.
photo
OscarthePug   03:20 AM on 4/22/2010
Two of the most culpable players in the financial fiasco were Moodys and Standard and Poors. If Moodys is stonewalli­ng the congressio­nal investigat­ion by delaying its compliance with requests for documents and informatio­n that would shed light and assist in the investigat­ion, then that corporatio­n and its officers need to be held in contempt.

The credit rating agencies were instrument­al in facilitati­ng the financial meltdown. All three of them should be as cooperativ­e as possible and compliant with every aspect of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission­'s requests in a timely fashion.

They have so far escaped judicial prosecutio­n for their many unethical and probable illegal acts, so for any one of them to play hardball with a congressio­nal inquiry is simply too arrogant for words.
LLeGrande   03:39 AM on 4/22/2010
Contempt = Jail Until Compliance
photo
Thomasina Jefferson   03:45 AM on 4/22/2010
So indefinite detention is already possible?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StJames   11:03 AM on 4/22/2010
Hi Oscar....s­ooner or later a whistle blower will appear...
schatsie   08:26 PM on 4/22/2010
Yes, and then Holder will lock that person up for something or other.....­.
photo
hottpotat0   02:44 AM on 4/22/2010
RUN OUT THE CLOCK?????­??????????­??????????

THEY WILL BE SHREDDING DOCUMENTS TILL DECEMBER!!­!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

Twitter Edition