Bulletin
Investor Alert
Global-recovery doubts unsettle markets

April 8, 2010, 1:43 p.m. EDT

Ex-Citigroup execs Prince and Rubin come in for criticism

Pair concede failure to foresee problems; Prince's apology evokes scorn

Explore related topics

By Ronald D. Orol, MarketWatch

WASHINGTON (MarketWatch) -- Former Citigroup Inc. chief executive Chuck Prince on Thursday told an exasperated financial-crisis inquiry panel he was sorry that his management team could not have foreseen the "unprecedented market collapse" that unfolded in 2008.

"What I've been struck by, in documents and testimony, is how much folks in the organization didn't know what was going on," said Phil Angelides, chief of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, after the portion of the hearing dealing with Citigroup /quotes/comstock/13*!c/quotes/nls/c (C 4.58, -0.07, -1.51%) wrapped up. Read "Prince and Rubin tackle 'too big to manage'"

"And I am struck by how much the two of you did not know what was going on," he told Prince and Robert Rubin, former chairman of Citigroup's executive committee and Treasury secretary in the Clinton administration. "You were in the suite of executive offices."


Reuters

Charles Prince, left, and Robert Rubin, former Citigroup executives in their appearance before the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission.

"Let me start by saying I'm sorry," Prince told the commission hearing on Capitol Hill.

"I'm sorry the financial crisis had such a devastating impact on our country. I'm sorry for the millions of people, average Americans who have lost their homes and I'm sorry that our management team, like so many others, could not see the unprecedented market collapse that lay before us," he said in a prepared statement.

Prince resigned as CEO in November 2007, as up to $11 billion in write-offs came to light. See MarketWatch's 2007 chronology as the crisis enveloped Citigroup.

Citigroup received a $45 billion federal bailout in two installments late in 2008 under the Troubled Asset Relief Program. Citigroup still owes $25 billion to the U.S. government, which owns a 27% share stake.

Defending their tenure

Greenspan defends his tenure at the Fed

Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan denied that the U.S. central bank helped inflate housing prices and isn't to blame for the subprime fiasco. Courtesy of Reuters.

Both Prince and Rubin said the crisis resulted from a confluence of factors, including a long period of low interest rates, a spike in housing prices, increases in consumer debt, and a subsequent "precipitous" drop in housing prices.

Regulators should limit bank leverage and hike capital and margin requirements, they argued.

However, commission members expressed outrage that the pair blamed others -- such as credit raters and regulators -- for the failures and didn't do their own analysis to identify problems with mortgage securities.

Citigroup packaged and sold these pooled securities -- considered a key contributor to the financial crisis when many of the underlying mortgages failed -- in the U.S. and abroad.

The securities contained subprime mortgages -- higher-risk home loans in which borrowers often weren't properly screened -- and received unrealistically rosy AAA ratings from credit-rating agencies.

Due diligence and blame

Members of the inquiry commission pointed to several reports brought to the attention of both Rubin and Prince regarding mortgage securities.

Page 1Page 2

First Take

HCA tests health of the IPO market

HCA Holdings Inc. has its first big healthcare assignment: testing the heart rates in the private equity industry.

55 min ago

MarketWatch's Latest Tweets

"@JavierTemprano thanks! we will fix the link."
12:16 p.m. EST, March 10, 2011 from MarketWatch

"Bank of Spain: 12 banks need to raise capital http://on.mktw.net/ia6kwD"
11:58 a.m. EST, March 10, 2011 from MarketWatch

"Santander CEO faces three-month ban http://bit.ly/ez7vAg"
11:18 a.m. EST, March 10, 2011 from MarketWatch

"HCA shares up 4% in initial NYSE trades following IPO http://on.mktw.net/gEHLyL"
10:07 a.m. EST, March 10, 2011 from MarketWatch

"Dow industrials down as much as 200 points in opening half-hour; McDonald's is sole gainer http://on.mktw.net/fLGgyC"
10:03 a.m. EST, March 10, 2011 from MarketWatch

/quotes/comstock/13*!c/quotes/nls/c Citigroup Inc (C)
/marketstate/country/US The market is open12:41:03 pm The market is closed12:41:03 pm
$ 4.58
Change -0.07 -1.51%
Volume 178.51m Real time quotes

Featured Stories

ALERT:

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.

Email address or display name

Password

Forgot password?