Moody’s Chief Says CDO Ratings ‘Deeply Disappointing’ (Update3)
June 02, 2010, 11:54 AM EDT(Updates with comment from former executive Witt in 11th paragraph.)
By Matthew Leising and Andrew Frye
June 2 (Bloomberg) -- Moody’s Corp. Chief Executive Officer Raymond McDaniel said his company’s ratings of collateralized debt obligations and residential mortgage securities in the past several years have been “deeply disappointing.”
McDaniel said the collapse of the housing market and subsequent economic slump were of a magnitude “many of us would have once thought unimaginable,” according to written testimony submitted to the U.S. Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission for a hearing today in New York on credit ratings. He said he is proud of Moody’s reputation and the firm’s record of 100 years of rating trillions of dollars in debt.
“However, the performance of our credit ratings for U.S. residential mortgage-backed securities and related collateralized debt obligations over the past several years has been deeply disappointing,” he said. “Moody’s is certainly not satisfied with the performance of these ratings.”
Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s and Fitch Ratings face scrutiny by Congress and state insurance regulators after assigning top grades to U.S. subprime-mortgage bonds just before that market collapsed in 2007, sparking the financial crisis. Moody’s said last month it may be sued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for filing false and misleading descriptions of its credit-ratings policies.
Warren Buffett, the billionaire chairman of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. and Moody Corp.’s largest shareholder, is also scheduled to testify. Buffett declined to provide his written testimony in advance, according to the FCIC. He had to be subpoenaed to be compelled to appear today, said Tucker Warren, a spokesman for the inquiry commission.
‘Not Pretty’
In his opening remarks, Chairman Phil Angelides said, “To be blunt, the picture is not pretty.” He added that “Moody’s did very well. The investors who relied on Moody’s ratings did not do so well.”
Angelides characterized the ratings service as a “triple-A factory,” saying that it assigned the top grade to 42,625 residential mortgage-backed securities from 2000 to 2007.
“In 2006 alone, Moody’s gave 9,029 mortgage-backed securities a triple-A rating,” said Angelides, whose panel was created to investigate the causes of the financial crisis as Congress debates the most sweeping overhaul of banking regulations since the Great Depression. “To put that in perspective, Moody’s currently bestows its triple-A rating on just four American corporations.”
AAA Downgrades
Many high-level ratings had to be lowered. In 2006, 83 percent of triple-A products were downgraded and in 2007, 89 percent of those considered investment grade were reduced to junk, Angelides said.
“This comes as close as you can to the very product being fraudulent or of no use to the marketplace in reality,” he said.
Bankers “always wanted higher ratings or the bigger triple-A tranches, and they would work hard to achieve that,” Gary Witt, a former managing director at Moody’s Investors Service’s structured derivatives products group, told the commission. “They would just pull any lever basically that they could.”
Former employee Eric Kolchinsky testified today that $488 million of collateral in a 2006 deal, rated by Moody’s while he worked there, has been downgraded to junk. No payments are being made, as the debt is in default, and this wasn’t even one of the worst performers among the securitized products the company graded, he said.
Time Pressure
To understand what happened, it’s crucial to realize the time pressure that analysts and others at the firm were under, Kolchinsky said.
“The banker gave us hardly any notice or any documentation or time to analyze this deal,” said Kolchinsky. Previously, analysts would have been given two months to do so, he said. In this case they received some information one day before the security was closed, Kolchinsky said.
“We certainly had a conveyor belt and felt that way” about the speed of ratings being produced, he said.
He also said “it was very clear” that his future at the firm and compensation depended on the market share that he brought in. “That was reinforced in many ways, especially with these e-mails that were sent out at least quarterly and occasionally monthly.”
Kolchinsky has said Moody’s violated securities laws by knowingly providing “incorrect” ratings. The company has denied the claim.
Congressional Bills
The U.S. Senate in May approved a plan to allow regulators, instead of bond issuers, to choose who rates asset-backed securities after investors said the ratings companies inflated assessments of mortgage bonds because they were paid by Wall Street firms selling the debt. A panel, overseen by the SEC, would assign a credit-ratings company to evaluate an offering.
The proposal is part of a larger financial reform package that the Senate passed last month. After being reconciled with the House version of the bill, it must be signed by President Barack Obama to become law.
Moody’s shares gained 58 cents, or 3 percent, to $19.88 at 11:49 a.m. in New York Stock Exchange composite trading. They had lost more than 30 percent this year through yesterday.
S&P and Fitch representatives weren’t invited to speak at the hearing today because their testimony wasn’t needed to understand issues with the credit-ratings industry, said Warren, the FCIC spokesman.
The fact that only Moody’s executives will appear today isn’t related to its being notified by the SEC that the company may be sued, Warren said.
Buffett Sells
Buffett sold Moody’s stock in each of the last three quarters, reducing a stake that had remained steady at 48 million shares since 2000. Buffett, who oversees a U.S. equity portfolio with a market value of $50.9 billion at the end of March, invests in firms that he thinks have long-term competitive advantages.
Moody’s, whose founder John Moody created credit grades a century ago, competes with McGraw-Hill Cos.’s S&P unit and Fitch Ratings for business assigning grades to corporate debt and mortgage bonds.
--With assistance from Jesse Westbrook and Alison Vekshin in Washington and Sapna Maheshwari in New York. Editors: Richard Bedard, Dan Reichl, Dan Kraut
To contact the reporters on this story: Matthew Leising in New York at mleising@bloomberg.net; Andrew Frye in New York at afrye@bloomberg.net.
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Dan Kraut at dkraut2@bloomberg.net; Alan Goldstein at agoldstein5@bloomberg.net.
