Greenspan defends legacy, jabs Hill

Updated: 4/8/10 8:11 AM EDT
Text Size
  • -
  • +
  • reset
Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan continued to sidestep attempts to force him to admit to specific mistakes at Wednesday's hearing.
Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan continued to sidestep attempts to force him to admit to specific mistakes at Wednesday's hearing. AP Photo

The Politico 44 / Click Story Widget Requires Adobe Flash Player.

Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve, continued his crusade to defend his legacy, saying he was right 70 percent of the time during his 21 years in public service.

Greenspan told a panel investigating the collapse of financial markets that banks should be required to hold more capital and traders more collateral — the "only" steps that would help soften the blow of a future crisis.

Policies that the Fed put in place were not enough to "stop the surge of subprime lending," he said, but things are better than they would've been without the board's guidance.

Greenspan has consistently sidestepped the panel's attempts to force him to admit to specific mistakes. He called retrospection about what-ifs a "futile activity."

The crux of Greenspan's argument was that in addition to higher capital and collateral requirements, stricter "enforcement against misrepresentation and fraud” is necessary so that losses are restricted to investors who “seek abnormal returns.”

Greenspan also took pointed shots at Congress, saying that there was "remarkable" pressure on the Fed to enhance lending. He said there was "a lot of amnesia" emerging from Capitol Hill among lawmakers calling for stricter regulation. There was "fairly broad consensus" that increased home ownership was a positive trend.

The committee is beginning three days of hearings on securitization and regulation of subprime lending. On Wednesday, it will hear from former Citigroup risk executives. Robert Rubin, the former chairman of Citigroup and Clinton administration treasury secretary, will testify Thursday, as will the comptroller of the currency.

Greenspan, in his prepared remarks, continued to say that the impact of regulation on financial markets is limited. But, he said, the rules in place did fail to regulate a market leading, many believe, to a meltdown of the economy.

“Even with the breakdown of private risk management and the collapse of private counterparty credit surveillance, the financial system would have held together had the second bulwark against our crisis — our regulatory system — functioned effectively,” Greenspan said in prepared remarks. “But under crisis pressure, it, too, failed.”

But Brooksley Born, a panel member and former chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, questioned whether the Fed, under Greenspan, failed in part because of his negative view on regulation.

“The notion that somehow that my views on regulation were predominant and effective as influencing the Congress is something you may have perceived. It didn’t look that way from my point of view,” Greenspan replied, in his most defensive answer of the morning.

“I ran my office as required by law and there are an awful lot of laws I would not have constructed in the way they were constructed, I enforced them nonetheless,” Greenspan said.

Greenspan also took a shot at the idea of "too big to fail" — the notion that some financial institutions cannot be allowed to collapse because of the damage it would cause to the broader economy. He told the committee in prepared remarks that the doctrine "can not be allowed to stand" because it encourages banks to take on too much risk.

The 84-year-old Greenspan did offer a sliver of criticism of the Fed, saying that the structure of the New York Fed "has to be thought through."

At about 11:45, as panel chairman Phil Angelides was announcing that he was wrapping up the segment with Greenspan, the power in cavernous Rayburn hearing room went off. The lights shut down and Greenspan remained sitting at the witness table.

With the curtains open, and light pouring through the floor-to-ceiling windows behind the panel, the chairman asked the question many wanted to ask. Angelides asked Greenspan if he thought there was a failure of regulation in the financial system.

With the microphones off, little was audible from the former chairman, and Angelides said that Greenspan gave a "lights out" performance.

Read more stories in Congress

Readers' Comments (48)

Show the first 20 comments
  1. avatar for user Doran
    Doran
    Party: Independent
    Reply #1
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:00 PM EST
  2. default avatar for user EMZC
    EMZC
    Party: Independent
    Reply #2
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:22 PM EST
  3. default avatar for user ewor
    ewor
    Party: Independent
    Reply #3
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:30 PM EST
  4. avatar for user Dread-neck
    Dread-neck
    Party: Conservative
    Reply #4
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:48 PM EST
  5. default avatar for user kalamere
    kalamere
    Party: N/A
    Reply #5
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:54 PM EST
  6. avatar for user ROEg
    ROEg
    Party: Libertarian
    Reply #6
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:57 PM EST
  7. default avatar for user DaveK
    DaveK
    Party: Independent
    Reply #7
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 12:57 PM EST
  8. default avatar for user cosimdm
    cosimdm
    Party: N/A
    Reply #8
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:09 PM EST
  9. default avatar for user cosimdm
    cosimdm
    Party: N/A
    Reply #9
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:09 PM EST
  10. default avatar for user skint
    skint
    Party: Independent
    Reply #10
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:10 PM EST
  11. avatar for user jackieaxe
    jackieaxe
    Party: Libertarian
    Reply #11
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:12 PM EST
  12. default avatar for user Joe_D
    Joe_D
    Party: Conservative
    Reply #12
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:24 PM EST
  13. default avatar for user winsom88
    winsom88
    Party: Independent
    Reply #13
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:38 PM EST
  14. default avatar for user docbraden
    docbraden
    Party: Independent
    Reply #14
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:45 PM EST
  15. default avatar for user J. E. Dundee
    J. E. Dundee
    Party: NA
    Reply #15
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:50 PM EST
  16. default avatar for user skint
    skint
    Party: Independent
    Reply #16
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 1:53 PM EST
  17. avatar for user HalfPastLate
    HalfPastLate
    Party: Independent
    Reply #17
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 2:06 PM EST
  18. default avatar for user skint
    skint
    Party: Independent
    Reply #18
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 2:32 PM EST
  19. avatar for user ElPatricio
    ElPatricio
    Party: Green
    Reply #19
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 2:54 PM EST
  20. default avatar for user Darby64
    Darby64
    Party: Independent
    Reply #20
    Apr. 7, 2010 - 3:02 PM EST
Read all 48 comments in our forum

YOU NEED TO LOG IN TO USE THIS SYSTEM!

  • Email is Required
  • Password is Required

If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register Now!

Comment on this article

Greenspan defends legacy, jabs Hill

  1. Message is Required
    (9000 chars max)
  2. (200 chars max)
Hear POLITICO on-demand from your smartphone
Get Adobe Flash player

Pollitico

The blame game
Which party shares more blame for the gloomy economy?

Wuerking Drawings

Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
Wuerker Cartoon
See all