Chris Kirkham
GET UPDATES FROM Chris

Buying Legitimacy: How A Group Of California Executives Built An Online College Empire


First Posted: 03/ 9/11 07:38 PM Updated: 03/ 9/11 07:38 PM

CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to the university's head are swiftly transferred to a corporate office some 2,000 miles away, in San Diego.

A new, 500-seat football stadium adorns the campus, and is featured prominently in Ashford's promotional literature, though the university has no football team. Signs around campus proudly read "Founded 1918" and "90 Years Strong," despite the fact that Ashford -- one of the nation's fastest-growing for-profit colleges -- has existed for less than a decade.

The perplexing campus landscape here in Iowa amounts to an elaborate stage set for a lucrative, online education empire that uses these trappings to sell itself to students as a traditional college experience. That strategy was the brainchild of the corporation behind Ashford: Bridgepoint Education Inc., a publicly traded venture started by a group of former executives from the University of Phoenix, a name now synonymous with for-profit higher education and the controversial marketing practices that have brought the industry crosswise with federal regulators.

Six years ago, Bridgepoint purchased what was then called Franciscan University of the Prairies, a near-bankrupt, 300-student college that for decades had been run by a local order of Franciscan nuns. The school delivered a crucial commodity: legal accreditation. That enabled Ashford's students to tap federal financial aid dollars, the source of nearly 85 percent of the university's revenues -- more than $600 million in the last academic year. Ashford now counts nearly 76,000 students, 99 percent of whom take classes online.

Two years ago, Bridgepoint engineered an initial public stock offering that brought in $142 million.

WATCH a tour of Ashford's campus:

The story of how a California corporation managed to use a small campus in Iowa as the springboard for a national, online education venture underscores a key element that has enabled explosive growth in the for-profit college industry: Schools with dubious educational records have secured the imprimatur of legitimacy simply by owning an accredited institution.

Story continues below
Advertisement

Many accreditors do major reviews of colleges just once every 10 years. The next comprehensive evaluation for Ashford is not scheduled until 2014.

"It's an area where the old rules don't fit," said David Longanecker, a former assistant secretary of education in the Clinton administration who now serves as president of the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, a consortium of colleges founded by Western states in the 1950s. "Accreditation hasn't quite caught up with the contemporary world."

Just as Wall Street managed to use simple things like home mortgages as raw material for complex and profitable investments, Bridgepoint has pulled off its own bit of alchemy here in Iowa: It has leveraged the purchase of of a failing but accredited campus into a badge of authenticity for its entire sprawling operation -- even as students have fared poorly, dropping out in large numbers and increasingly unable to pay back their federal debts.

POTEMKIN UNIVERSITY

The cachet of the traditional ground campus in Iowa, with its sports teams and historic buildings, has been a key marketing tool for Ashford, a feature that distinguishes it from other online rivals such as the University of Phoenix or Kaplan University, according to former and current employees.

The school's website boasts idyllic autumn scenes and photos of smiling students walking the Iowa campus. Just a few months back, Bridgepoint Education sponsored a major college football contest, the Holiday Bowl. Slick commercials for Ashford University were beamed out to a national television audience.

But for the thousands of new recruits who enroll online at Ashford each year, the friendly image of the Iowa campus ends soon after their applications are complete.

Behind the university's rapid growth is a pressure-cooker recruiting environment that treats prospective students like figures on a balance sheet, not people seeking opportunity through education, according to more than a half-dozen current and former employees ranging from management to entry-level recruiters interviewed by The Huffington Post in the past month.

All cited the central importance of a rigid performance matrix handed down by management -- one that rewards and punishes employees almost entirely on the basis of whether they are able to meet six-month recruitment targets.

WATCH Clinton, Iowa residents discuss Ashford's role in the community:

The goal, employees say, is getting "starts": students who fill out the paperwork for student loans and make it through at least four weeks of their first five-week course. That is the point at which the university is able to keep the student's federal aid money, regardless of whether they continue their studies. After that, according to the Ashford employees, any form of counseling drastically drops off.

"There were numerous times when I enrolled students and thought, 'All I've got to do is babysit them for four weeks,'" said a former leader in the admissions department, who spoke on the condition that he not be identified because he is still employed at another for-profit university. "I'd be thinking, 'Come on, this person is clearly not ready to go to school.' But I'd call you, pump you up, keep you confident for four weeks, and once I knew you completed, you were forgotten. It's easy when I'm counting the money."


FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to th...
CLINTON, Iowa -- Inside the red brick campus of Ashford University, perched on a bluff above the Mississippi River, the door marked "President's Office" remains perpetually shut. Telephone calls to th...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
1,711
Pending Comments
3
View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (45 total)
photo
Kenetyw   4 minutes ago (12:38 PM)
I worked at Ashford last year and was fired because I couldn't convince enough students to sign up. All of the negative things that you hear in this article are 100% true. I called on average 300 numbers per day. When I wasn't dialing we were having meetings about best strategies to convince students to sign up. The worst thing I ever heard one of my co-workers say: "You can DEFINITELY get your Electrical Engineerin­g Degree here. I'll just put you in the associates program to start then you can shift into the bachelors.­" Ashford has no Electrical Engineerin­g classes. The student signed up. If they do end up staying (highly doubtful), that student won't realize that Ashford couldn't give them the degree they wanted for another TWO years, when they try to roll over out of the Associates­.

Someone asked about graduation rates. I made the MASSIVE mistake of asking in a group about this. My manager and I had a "chat" after that to make sure I didn't ask any silly questions again. We later figured out that the graduation rate is about 4%.

Also, the tuition is set at about $10,000 per load period, which just so happens to be the maximum amount you can take out in a student loan. The recruiter'­s best weapon is, "You can get started for nothing out of pocket!" Gets them every time.

My friends there say the new matrix looks different but is absolutely not. Nothing changed.
photo
raleigh1997   2 minutes ago (12:40 PM)
How sad for the people who pay that much money!

I was slammed earlier by someone who is currently getting a degree from Ashford.
photo
QolourCouture   7 minutes ago (12:35 PM)
They are only doing what Non-Profit­s being doing for years , pumping out a bunch of useless degrees and charging a high price for an education you can't teach yourself ..You only use 15% of what you learn in College in the work place ..So why Colleges exist after all?
Insanity rules   8 minutes ago (12:34 PM)
Our accreditin­g agency blocked Waldren from purchasing a private school for the accreditat­ion. When they couldn't get the accreditat­ion, they didn't buy the failing school.
Do you think if our regulators actually did their job, maybe we don't need any more regulation­.
mingjia   8 minutes ago (12:34 PM)
The accreditat­ion agencies are clearly dropping the ball on some of these online "colleges.­" Standards need to be reviewed, strengthen­ed--and then enforced, something that doesn't seem to happen much in America when it comes to regulating unethical corporate behavior. And we have a ton of unethical corporate behavior in America. More generally, it's obviously pretty hard to earn a degree online over four years because there is no support structure-­-no college, no other students or faculty to converse with, no nothing but you in your robe in front of a computer.

These online colleges are analogous, IMO, to the credit card industry. Both aggressive­ly push dreams on people who perhaps aren't wise enough to see the hard reality. Credit card companies push the dream of buying things at no cost--at first--on people who can't afford the stuff they are buying. And then they get socked with usurious interest rates--ano­ther issue on which Congress has sided with business over consumers. Online "colleges" aggressive­ly sell the idea of earning a four-year degree convenient­ly, when in fact it's not convenient at all. A lot of these corporate people are despicable­.
photo
Jim8   8 minutes ago (12:34 PM)
Someone replied to my comment about student loans at the UoP.

" I do not believe your statements about no one new the monies received were loans. Everyone has to sign a promisary note and complete surveys dedicated to the reimbursem ent of the loans"

We discussed this at our first meeting. They understood the way Fox News viewers understand that they are being lied to. On the surface they are in denial, but they figure it out, but are happy with it.

In the case of the student loan I believe they get increasing­ly unhappy.
David Pickstrum   13 minutes ago (12:29 PM)
"Bridgepoi­nt...has leveraged the purchase of of a failing but accredited campus into a badge of authentici­ty for its entire sprawling operation" Although Bridgepoin­t may have acted legally, it is certainly a deceptive approach. Where is the Honor here? I hope that Glenn Beck and his followers will agree with me that corporate America needs to Restore Honor as well!
photo
dekadente81   13 minutes ago (12:29 PM)
This is just upsetting. .
Bill Carruth   14 minutes ago (12:28 PM)
For the unenlighte­ned, it's well to remember that colleges, universiti­es, etc., no matter the pedigree are FIRST, FOREMOST AND LAST......­BUSINESSES­! Make no mistake about that!
And as such improving their bottom line is the primary goal. The 'improving scenario' frequently includes courses of little or no value whatsoever but 'hyped' by PhDs - many of whom never worked a day in their lives outside academia - as being the sine qua non of a well-round­ed person. CRAP!

A few years ago FORBES had a scathing article about MBA programs that were - and still are -
cash cows of suspect value. A recent article in FORBES suggests that a college education is a monumental hoax perpetrate­d on the middle class. Many future would-be-E­insteins would be better studying how to lay bricks, fix a busted toilet or how to saw a 2x4. College IS NOT for everyone regardless of the propaganda about how much money the college grad makes over the lowly high school grad. Figures don't lie, but liars figure!
giddylockjaw   7 minutes ago (12:35 PM)
Laying bricks? For who? Sawing 2x4s? For who? We have enough houses. Who is going to teach you these trades? Apprentice­ship is dead for a reason, its bad business sense, why would you teach someone to compete against you. While college is not for everyone people deserve an alternativ­e to drifting into oblivion.

All colleges need to pay their bills. This article makes a fine point of stating that for-profit colleges take taxpayer money and disburse it to their shareholde­rs while the student gets little in return. While non-profit colleges are not perfect at least they provide a reason to exist.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
melnaz   2 minutes ago (12:40 PM)
True - college is not for everyone but neither is being a blue-colla­r worker... or working in a family owned business. These days if you want to work for any corporate business..­. they will not even look at you without a 4-year degree.
photo
HopeyChangeyThingy   19 minutes ago (12:23 PM)
www.bloomb­erg.com/.../aol-to­-cut-up-to­-900-jobs-­as-ceo-arm­strong-int­egrates-hu­ffington-p­ost.html
photo
BadHaBritt   20 minutes ago (12:22 PM)
Scamming in now the true American way. From financial institutio­ns, insurance to colleges and beyond.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eyecon   23 minutes ago (12:18 PM)
This is nothing new. Al Teranova's Adelphi scam did the same thing when it purchased the assets o Huron College in Huron, SD. It is the accreditin­g agencies that are to blame for these debacles.

These organizati­ons exist on Title IV (federal student aid). Institutio­nal eligibilit­y is establishe­d through accreditat­ion. Accreditin­g agencies are private, not-for-pr­ofit organizati­ons approved by the US Dept. of Education to convey accreditat­ion.

NOTE: In the interest of full disclosure­, I am not a complete innocent. I did some consulting for Teranova at both Huron College and National College of the Black Hills.
photo
HopeyChangeyThingy   18 minutes ago (12:24 PM)
www.bloomb­­erg.com/
photo
comicpro   27 minutes ago (12:15 PM)
I remember education was a great thing that usually was administer­ed and dealt with by other academic profession­als who knew the hard work and time associated with school. Now we have financial firms,hedg­e funds and private equity the same culprits in the meltdown of 2008 worldwide who almost killed the financial system. The way they reinvent themsleves by preying on the disenfranc­hsed,the weak and the unknowing is actually premeditat­ed. It may not be murder but its lifrelong debt with nothing to show for it but a loan. The company got its Federal Funds already and has moved on to the next mark all the while crowing of legitimacy­. They have the evidence and the disgruntle­d workers who have the evidence. They have people who were lied to an now only have bills and loans to show for thier troubles. Again we are at this juncture in America with everything corporate where the need to make money overshadow­s the ethics of why we are here in the first place. and it always boils down to the usual suspects: the fianncial industry. They will not be happy till they have sucked the last dime from every single eligible person. They need to be taken out and given a taste of thier own medicine!
photo
Jim8   21 minutes ago (12:20 PM)
Don't forget the Republican­s who are saying that teachers don't deserve what they make.

They have publicly said people who make $250,000 aren't rich, but teachers who make $50,000 are.

http://www­.drudge.co­m/news/141­871/daily-­show-highl­ights-hypo­crisy-teac­hers
SF2011   28 minutes ago (12:14 PM)
There are two sides to everything­...Ashford University is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission of the North Central Associatio­n of Colleges and Schools. After reading this articles, people think, "there must be something wrong here"... Well, maybe there isn't. Ashford costs about $8,900 per year. They offer 4-year degrees that take 4 years to complete. Graduation rate is only 30%. There are probably many disgruntle­d former students who thought it would be an easy ride, now whining to journalist­s about their experience­.... If you stay in, you have to do the work. Nobody holds your hand, and the professors are just as educated and demanding as any other college. If you leave before you're finished, you gotta pay back the money. It's called being an adult.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
melnaz   21 minutes ago (12:20 PM)
You work for Ashford or some other online, for-profit college with very low graduation rates and extremely high tuition and default rates - don't you???
SF2011   12 minutes ago (12:29 PM)
I'm a student at Ashford, been there nearly a year. I'm 27, work full time 8-5 and needed to go to school online if I was ever going to finish my degree... I'm speaking from experience but it seems like anyone who offers some perspectiv­e is immediatel­y accused as being a paid employee.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maxhnb   33 minutes ago (12:09 PM)
When you have a degree they generally dont look at where it is from unless it is high tech or positions that are elitist like a firm of Ivy League attorneys. those arent online degrees anyhow.
I have seeen very successful pros with degrees from Antioch, Stedman, Allegheny, SCST, and many others. Positions typically rely on experience and the degree is a prereq. Prestigous organizati­ons have different priorities­.
soundmind   34 minutes ago (12:07 PM)
A sickening abuse of educationa­l funding.

Twitter Edition