A Short History of Western Thought by Stephen Trombley – review

An impressive survey of philosophy packs a lot into 2,500 years

Thomas Aquinas
Thomas Aquinas, the 13th-century Italian philosopher and theologian. Photograph: Interfoto/Alamy

To condense the history of western thought to around 50,000 words is the literary equivalent of trying to reproduce the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel on the inside of a matchbox. So it is to writer and film-maker Stephen Trombley's tremendous credit that his intellectual miniaturisation, while inevitably losing almost all the detail, leaves very little out and renders most of the original characters and scenes distinctive and recognisable.

The book is a kind of history of philosophy plus, containing all the usual thinkers from the pre-Socratics to the post-structuralists. Most rival volumes, however, spend a long time in ancient Greece, then jump to 16th-century Europe, with a short sojourn in imperial Rome, a few words from Augustine, and a cup of medieval tea with Saints Anselm and Aquinas. It's a bit like reading the Bible by skipping all but a few Psalms and Proverbs between the Pentateuch and the Gospels.

No such lazy skipping for Trombley, who fills the gaps with a greater than usual emphasis on the place of religion in the development of western thought. Increasingly familiar is the role of the golden age of Islam in the development of philosophy, both in the transmission of ancient Greek texts to Europe and in its own innovations. More unusual is the extent to which Trombley discusses the development of Christian thought. This enables us to see the later French, German and Scottish enlightenments (no simplistic reduction to the Enlightenment here) as emerging from a gradual growth of the importance of the individual that has its roots in Christian theology.

This theme of the "liberation of the individual" is what comes closest to giving the book a central narrative. Trombley identifies Augustine's Confessions as "the first text in which the first-person singular voice, the I, comes into play" in spiritual and intellectual discourse. A thousand years later, this seed would flower in the Reformation's emphasis on the individual's direct relationship to God.

Trombley also makes space for the social and technological developments that nudged intellectual changes. For instance, the significance of printing and the availability of books in the vernacular, although widely acknowledged, is often skipped over in histories of ideas. Trombley has plenty of lesser-known examples, such as how the expulsion of the Jews from Spain in 1492 helped top up the intellectual resources of the Ottoman empire, thanks to Sultan Bayezid's offer of citizenship to the exiles.

Indeed, such is the breadth of reference in this book that even experts who might blanch at the cursory treatment of their specialised subjects are bound to come across numerous things they didn't know. These range from interesting trivia, such as the fact that the word "dunce" derives from a term of abuse for followers of the 13th-century scholastic Duns Scotus; to more significant revelations, such as ibn Qurra's argument that the world revolved around the sun, which predates Copernicus by six centuries. As for the medieval riddle: how many angels can you fit on a pin head? The answer, according to Aquinas, is infinitely many, since "only a body fills a space" and angels are not bodies.

Given the absurdly ambitious range of the books, there are bound to be simplifications, some of which are misleading, if not actually incorrect. A more avoidable flaw is that, in the desire to cram as much in as possible, the text does sometimes resort to lists ("Nietzsche's key works include …") On other occasions, an idea is presented so briefly that it just isn't clear, or it becomes a kind of tease.

The only real gripe I have, however, is the sometimes gratuitous inclusion of boxed quotations, many of which do not enhance the main text at all. Most bizarre is a single sentence from John Searle, which reads: "I want to explain how certain essential parts of mind, language and social reality work and how they form a coherent whole." Sorry, John, no time.

Trombley's history is too quick and large to be authoritative and comprehensive. But for an overview of the terrain, this includes more landmarks per square inch than most maps of this scale provide and suggests routes for many fascinating philosophical journeys.


Your IP address will be logged

Comments

1 comment, displaying oldest first

or to join the conversation

  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor
  • Soontopass

    8 January 2012 1:26PM

    I can't help feeling negatively towards books which purport to provide an overview of a subject as far-ranging and complex as Western Philosophy. Before I state why I must first confess to having found Russell's 'History of Western Philosophy' very useful for providing a vague idea of the subject's key thinkers before reading some of the works themselves. Even in this case though there is a great difference between an overview at 800 and odd pages and one at 50000 words.

    The beauty of philosophy is that it cannot be reduced in this way. The study of life is a reward in itself but never an end. Pick any thinker from Plato through to Merleau-Ponty and you will find contradictions, as they grasp about for a slippery scrap of truth. When they reach a conclusion it is usually tentative. When they do assert a dogmatic view it is often doubted or disowned in a later work (think Wittgenstein). This is the main problem with reducing these thinkers to a number of key ideas - especially in the space of 50000 words. The concepts they are wrestling with - ontology, epistemology etc. - are wildly contentious in every way, requiring incremental increases in understanding over time to pad out their meaning for oneself. There is simply no substitute for a healthy level of intellectual curiousity - which in turn gives rise to the sustained dedication needed to get to grips with these essential, but wisely sceptical thinkers.

    The only purpose a book like this can have in my view is to to provide a small degree of context for someone who has already decided to read some of the works themselves. Unfortunately in my experience these books are almost never used in this way. They are indicative of the contemporary desire for almost instant gratification - to substitute the hard-graft involved in examining the complexity of one's life and reduce it to a number of bite-sized ideas, which could be displayed as a series of instantly forgettable bullet-points on a powerpoint presentation. In short, the aim of many of these books is not to inspire further learning, but to allow the curious reader to feel learned without any conceptual understanding.

or to join the conversation

Find books to review, discuss, buy




Guardian Bookshop

This week's bestsellers

  1. 1.  Stop What You're Doing and Read This!

    £4.99

  2. 2.  Bigger Message

    by Martin Gayford £18.95

  3. 3.  Send Up the Clowns

    by Simon Hoggart £8.99

  4. 4.  Why It's Kicking Off Everywhere

    by Paul Mason £14.99

  5. 5.  100 Simple Things You Can Do to Prevent Alzheimer's

    by Jean Carper £10.99

Buy tickets for top music events

Compare and buy tickets for thousands of events

  1. Drake

    Drake

    Monday, 26 Mar, 2012

    O2 Arena - London

  2. Andrea Bocelli

    Andrea Bocelli

    Thursday, 8 Nov, 2012

    Odyssey Arena - Belfast

  3. Miles Kane

    Miles Kane

    Friday, 20 Apr, 2012

    Rock City - Nottingham

Tickets to more music events Browse tickets
Latest books added to lists | guardian.co.uk

Have your manuscript read

Bestsellers from the Guardian shop

Find the latest jobs in your sector:

Browse all jobs