Top Japan airlines ground Boeing 787s after emergency

The ANA flight made an emergency landing at Takamatsu

Related Stories

Japan's two main airlines have grounded their Boeing 787 Dreamliners after one was forced to make an emergency landing because of battery problems.

All Nippon Airways (ANA) grounded its fleet of 17 Dreamliners when its flight NH 692 from Yamaguchi Ube was forced to land shortly after take-off.

Japan Airlines followed suit, saying it would ground its fleet of seven 787s from 16 January until further notice.

This is the latest setback for Boeing and its problem-hit Dreamliner planes.

In recent weeks, Dreamliners have suffered issues including fuel leaks, a cracked cockpit window, brake problems and an electrical fire.

"You're nearing the tipping point where they need to regard this as a serious crisis," said Richard Aboulafia, a senior analyst with the Teal Group in Fairfax, Virginia.

"This is going to change people's perception of the aircraft if they don't act quickly."

Battery malfunction

On Wednesday, ANA's flight NH 692 left Yamaguchi Ube in western Japan at 08:10 local time (23:10 GMT) and headed for Tokyo's Haneda airport.

Analysis

There have been six separate safety incidents with Japanese owned 787s in the last week and a half. But they are not all equal.

The incident today was by far the most serious. Smoke inside an aircraft while in-flight is always a serious matter. That's why the plane was so quickly diverted, and probably why ANA and JAL have now ordered their fleets to be grounded.

It also looks like this incident may not be isolated. It appears very similar to an electrical fire on board a Japan Airlines 787 in the United States last week.

The source of that fire was the 787's lithium Ion battery pack. All the way back in 2007, the US Federal Aviation Administration expressed concern about the instillation of Lithium Ion batteries on board the 787 because of their known problem with so called "thermal runaway". It's a problem that has caused mobile phones and laptop computers to catch fire in the past.

The 787 is not the only aircraft to use Lithium Ion battery packs. The Airbus A380 uses a smaller number. And the upcoming Airbus A350 will use a much larger number.

Shortly after take-off, smoke was seen in the cockpit but not in the passenger compartment, and a strange smell was reported.

ANA says that it does not yet know the source of the smoke and is investigating the problem.

However, it added that the battery in the forward cargo hold was the same type as the one involved in a fire on another Dreamliner at a US airport last week.

The ANA flight landed at Takamatsu airport at 08:47 on Wednesday after the pilot saw an error message in the cockpit.

"There was a battery alert in the cockpit and there was an odd smell detected in the cockpit and cabin, and [the pilot] decided to make an emergency landing," said Osamu Shinobe, an ANA vice president, at a news conference.

ANA said that the 129 passengers and eight crew were evacuated, with a number of people sustaining minor injuries.

The Reuters news agency reported that five people were injured, while Bloomberg said that one person was sent to hospital. ANA officials were not immediately available to confirm the figures.

The BBC's correspondent in Tokyo, Rupert Wingfield-Hayes, said that local television footage showed emergency chutes were deployed from the plane. There were also fire trucks on the runway.

Market Reaction

Paul Lewis, a spokesman for Boeing, told the BBC that the planemaker was "aware of the diversion of a 787 operated by ANA to Takamatsu in western Japan".

He added that Boeing "will be working with our customer and the appropriate regulatory agencies".

Dreamliners in use

  • Air India: 5
  • All Nippon Airways (Japan): 17
  • Ethiopian Airlines: 4
  • Japan Airlines: 7
  • LAN Airlines (Chile): 3
  • Lot Polish Airlines: 2
  • Qatar Airways: 5
  • United Airlines (US) 6
  • Total: 49

Source: Boeing

The concerns have spread beyond Japan, however, not least because the Dreamliner was seen as Boeing's flagship new aeroplane and had attracted orders from many of the world's biggest and best-known airlines.

The 787 is said to be one of the most fuel-efficient in the industry, and Boeing delivered 46 Dreamliners to customers in 2012.

Following Wednesday's landing, India's aviation regulator said it would review the Dreamliner's safety and talk to parts makers.

Despite this, the regulator said it had no plans to ground the six Dreamliners that are currently being used by Air India.

Australia's Qantas Airways said its order for 15 Dreamliners remained on track. Its subsidiary Jetstar is due to take delivery of the first of its aircraft in the second half of this year.

United Airlines is the only US carrier currently flying Dreamliners, and the carrier said it was not taking any immediate action.

Closer look

Even before Wednesday's emergency landing, Boeing was facing an inquiry by Japanese and US authorities over its Dreamliner issues.

Last week, the US Federal Aviation Administration started a joint review with Boeing of the design, manufacturing and assembly of the Dreamliner.

On Tuesday, Japanese authorities said they would conduct an inquiry after two successive fuel leaks on a different 787 operated by Japan Airlines.

Inside the cockpit of the Dreamliner

On 8 January, Japan Airlines reported that a fire broke out on a 787 shortly after it landed in Boston. There have also been reports of brake issues.

"It is not abnormal for new aircraft to have some teething problems," said Chris de Lavigne of Frost and Sullivan in Singapore.

"There were initial issues with the Airbus A380 as well. Look where it is today; it is flying successfully and everyone seems to be happy with it."

However, he added that a lot would depend on the outcome of the two investigations.

"If it turns out to be a major issue and requires re-engineering to be done, then you may need to ground some of the planes or even the entire fleet."

Are you affected by the grounding of the Boeing 787s? Please share your comments and experiences

If you are happy to be contacted by a BBC journalist please leave a telephone number that we can contact you on. In some cases a selection of your comments will be published, displaying your name as you provide it and location, unless you state otherwise. Your contact details will never be published. When sending us pictures, video or eyewitness accounts at no time should you endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws. Please ensure you have read the terms and conditions.

Terms and conditions

More on This Story

Related Stories

From other news sites

* May require registration or subscription

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Hyundai Back on track?

    Hyundai hits redemption road in Detroit, writes BBC Autos' Jeffrey Jablansky

Programmes

  • Spencer Kelly riding a robotic spiderClick Watch

    It weighs 750 kilos and drives like a tank – meet the giant robotic spider being taken out for a spin

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

SCRIPT_URL=/news/business-21038128
SCRIPT_URI=http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-21038128
Country=us
IP_Is_Advertise_Combined=yes
IP_Is_UK_Combined=no
GEOIP_OVERRIDE=true
DetectedDevice=hi
Default_Edition=domestic
Default_Bandwidth=hi
FIDDLER_DefaultAudience=uk
FIDDLER_DefaultPlatform=hi
VARNISH_ON=1
FIDDLER_Audience=us
FIDDLER_Site=news
FIDDLER_Platform=hi
FIDDLER_PageType=
FIDDLER_AnalyticsCategory=business
FIDDLER_AssetID=21038128
FIDDLER_AudienceAgnostic=
FIDDLER_FileName=
FIDDLER_AssetIdDivider=/000/021/038
FIDDLER_AudienceForRequest=us
VARNISH_STORY=1
FIDDLER_DoNotFiddle=
CacheRoot=/data/content/archiveCache
SERVER_LOCATION=THNY
HOSTNAME=nolweb453.wtf.nolcontent.net
FMTJ_SERVER_ENV=live
SYSCFG_FMTJ_SERVER_ENV=live
SYSCFG_ARCHIVE_SERVER=http://archive.wtf.nolcontent.net
SYSCFG_OUTBOUND_INTERNET_PROXY=http://http-proxy:2112
SYSCFG_MARKETDATA_BACKEND=http://marketdatapages:1928
SYSCFG_MARKETDATA_CHART_PROXY=http://marketdatacharts:1987
SYSCFG_WCW_PHP_BACKEND=http://wcw-apps
SYSCFG_FORGE_PAL_BACKEND=http://pal-live
SYSCFG_QUOVALITE_SERVER=${QUOVALITE_SERVER}
SYSCFG_EXTERNAL_HOSTNAME=nolweb453.cwwtf.bbc.co.uk
SYSCFG_PREVIEW_ENABLED=false
SYSCFG_DEVELOPMENT_ENABLED=false
SYSCFG_REWRITE_LOG_ENABLED=false
SYSCFG_QUOVALITE_ENABLED=false
SYSCFG_ARCHIVE_LOOKUP_DISABLED=false
SYSCFG_FORGE_CACHE_DISABLED=false
SERVER_DOMAIN=www.bbc.co.uk
FIDDLER_VERSION=5.0.0
HTTP_USER_AGENT=Mozilla/5.0 (compatible
HTTP_ACCEPT=*/*
HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE=en
HTTP_HOST=www.bbc.co.uk
HTTP_X_CLUSTER_CLIENT_IP=23.22.39.206
HTTP_X_BACKEND_POOL=Journalism
HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING=gzip
HTTP_X_BBC_TRACE=0
HTTP_X_ESI_CAPABILITY=1
HTTP_X_GEOIP=1
HTTP_X_IP_IS_ADVERTISE_COMBINED=yes
HTTP_X_COUNTRY=us
HTTP_X_IP_IS_UK_COMBINED=no
HTTP_X_QUOVA_STATUS=Success
HTTP_X_GEOIP_CACHE=hit
HTTP_X_DEMI_VERSION=0.6.48
HTTP_X_DEMI_TYPE=
HTTP_X_DEMI_CACHE=hit
HTTP_X_DEMI=1
HTTP_X_ID_SIGNEDIN=0
HTTP_X_COOKIE_H4=
HTTP_X_COOKIE_LOCSERV=
HTTP_X_COOKIE_CKPS_D=
HTTP_X_VARNISH=1163966753
HTTP_COOKIE=BBC-UID=05a0ff4635dc9e5fb4990981c1c4bfc8f7074411c49401ae5a012484de95a8800Mozilla/5.0%20(compatible
HTTP_X_IP_ADDRESS=e4a6006e148d31817c83d322cadd4f559d0ae003c7a47d044d363339adefb;23.22.39.206
PATH=/sbin:/usr/sbin:/bin:/usr/bin
SERVER_SIGNATURE=
SERVER_SOFTWARE=Apache
SERVER_NAME=www.bbc.co.uk
SERVER_ADDR=192.168.212.74
SERVER_PORT=80
REMOTE_ADDR=23.22.39.206
DOCUMENT_ROOT=/data/content/www
SERVER_ADMIN=nol.livesite@bbc.co.uk
SCRIPT_FILENAME=/data/content/www/cps/asset/000/021/038/21038128_news_business_us_hi.stm
REMOTE_PORT=0
GATEWAY_INTERFACE=CGI/1.1
SERVER_PROTOCOL=HTTP/1.1
REQUEST_METHOD=GET
QUERY_STRING=blq_new_nav=1&blq_nav_color=orange&blq_identity=off&blq_language=en-gb&blq_footer_link_text_1=News%20Sources&blq_footer_link_url_1=/news/1/hi/help/3281815.stm&blq_footer_link_text_2=About%20BBC%20News&blq_footer_link_url_2=/news/1/hi/help/default.stm&blq_footer_link_text_3=&blq_footer_link_url_3=&identity_target_resource=http://identity/policies/dna/adult&blq_footer_color=transparent&IP_IS_ADVERTISE_COMBINED=yes&IP_IS_UK_COMBINED=no&ADS_ENABLED=&COUNTRY=us&blq_cachebust_journalism=1.21.9&blq_journalism_variant=1&blq_promo_optout=1&blq_gvl=3.5&blq_contact_us_url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/newswatch/ifs/hi/feedback/default.stm&blq_mobile_url=/news/mobile/&bbcpage_survey=off&bbcpage_surveysite=&bbcpage_survey_nopop=&survey_forceon=&blq_doctype=xhtml%2Brdfa&blq_footer_color=transparent&blq_masthead_opacity=40&blq_search_scope=news&blq_nedstat=1&blq_requirejs=on&blq_variant=&blq_istats_linktracking=true&blq_masthead_background=transparent-light
REQUEST_URI=/news/business-21038128
SCRIPT_NAME=/news/business-21038128
DATE_LOCAL=27
DATE_GMT=27
LAST_MODIFIED=45
DOCUMENT_URI=/news/business-21038128
USER_NAME=repman
DOCUMENT_NAME=21038128_news_business_us_hi.stm
CPS_ASSET_TYPE=story
CPS_ASSET_TYPE_CLASS=story
VELOCITY_DESIGN_VERSION=cream
VELOCITY_TEMPLATE_VERSION=v1_0
CPS_PLATFORM=hi
CPS_AUDIENCE=us
CPS_ASSET_ID=21038128
CPS_SITE=news
CPS_SITE_NAMESPACE=news
CPS_SITE_NAME=BBC News
CPS_SECTION=business
CPS_SECTION_DISPLAY_NAME=Business
CPS_SECTION_SKIN=business
CPS_SECTION_PATH=Business
CPS_URI=/news/business-21038128
CPS_PREVIEW=false
CPS_BUILD_VERSION=6.2.120-RC3
CPS_STATS_COUNTERNAME=news.business.story.21038128.page
CPS_FIRST_PUBLISH_TIMESTAMP=2013-01-16T00:57:10+00:00
CPS_LAST_EDITORIAL_UPDATE_TIMESTAMP=2013-01-16T07:17:36+00:00
CPS_COMMENTS_ENABLED=false
CPS_PAGE_TITLE_URL_ENCODED=BBC+News+-+Top+Japan+airlines+ground+Boeing+787s+after+emergency
CPS_HEADLINE_SHORT_URL_ENCODED=Japan+emergency+hits+Dreamliners
HOST_STATIC=http://news.bbcimg.co.uk
CSS_HI_SHARED=3_0_9/cream
INC_HI_SHARED=3_0_6/cream
IMG_HI_SHARED=3_0_0/cream
JS_VIEW_VERSION=0.0
CSS_HI_NEWS=1_4_35/cream
INC_HI_NEWS=2_0_16/cream
IMG_HI_NEWS=1_0_2/cream
CSS_HI_VOTE_2012=1_0_5/cream
INC_HI_VOTE_2012=1_0_5/cream
IMG_HI_VOTE_2012=1_0_0/cream
JS_HI_VOTE_2012=1_0_5/cream
CPS_HTTP_HOST_DOMAIN=http://www.bbc.co.uk
CPS_AD_KEYWORD=asiabusiness
PULSE_ENABLED=yes
blq_host=wwwimg.bbc.co.uk
blq_server=journalism
blq_webservice_release=r63
blq_cache=cached/
blq_webservice_variant=journalism
blq_web_service=on
blq_identity=off
identity_target_resource=http://identity/policies/dna/adult
blq_core_cache=3
blq_cachebust_journalism=1.21.9
blq_new_nav=1
blq_journalism_variant=1
blq_promo_optout=1
blq_gvl=3.5
blq_masthead_background=transparent-light
blq_doctype=xhtml%2Brdfa
bbcpage_survey=off
blq_footer_color=transparent
blq_language=en-gb
blq_request_uri=http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-21038128
blq_requirejs=on
blq_istats_linktracking=true
blq_nedstat=1
blq_nedstat_geoedition=us
blq_nedstat_countername=news.business.story.21038128.page
blq_nedstat_labels=cps_asset_id=21038128&page_type=story&section=business&app_version=6.2.120-RC3&first_pub=2013-01-16T00:57:10+00:00&last_editorial_update=2013-01-16T07:17:36+00:00&title=Japan+emergency+hits+Dreamliners&comments_box=false&cps_media_type=&cps_media_state=&app_type=web&ml_name=SSI&ml_version=0.14.4&language=en-GB
blq_search_scope=news
blq_mobile_url=/news/mobile/
blq_low_graphics_url=text_only.stm
blq_nav_color=orange
blq_footer_link_url_1=/news/1/hi/help/3281815.stm
blq_footer_link_text_1=News%20Sources
blq_footer_link_url_2=/news/1/hi/help/default.stm
blq_footer_link_text_2=About%20BBC%20News
blq_masthead_opacity=40
blq_contact_us_url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/newswatch/ifs/hi/feedback/default.stm
apple-touch-icon=/nol/shared/img/iphone-news.png
blq_query=blq_new_nav=1&blq_nav_color=orange&blq_identity=off&blq_language=en-gb&blq_footer_link_text_1=News%20Sources&blq_footer_link_url_1=/news/1/hi/help/3281815.stm&blq_footer_link_text_2=About%20BBC%20News&blq_footer_link_url_2=/news/1/hi/help/default.stm&blq_footer_link_text_3=&blq_footer_link_url_3=&identity_target_resource=http://identity/policies/dna/adult&blq_footer_color=transparent&IP_IS_ADVERTISE_COMBINED=yes&IP_IS_UK_COMBINED=no&ADS_ENABLED=&COUNTRY=us&blq_cachebust_journalism=1.21.9&blq_journalism_variant=1&blq_promo_optout=1&blq_gvl=3.5&blq_contact_us_url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/newswatch/ifs/hi/feedback/default.stm&blq_mobile_url=/news/mobile/&bbcpage_survey=off&bbcpage_surveysite=&bbcpage_survey_nopop=&survey_forceon=&blq_doctype=xhtml%2Brdfa&blq_footer_color=transparent&blq_masthead_opacity=40&blq_search_scope=news&blq_nedstat=1&blq_requirejs=on&blq_variant=&blq_istats_linktracking=true&blq_masthead_background=transparent-light
tmp_qs=
QUERY_STRING_UNESCAPED=blq_new_nav=1\&blq_nav_color=orange\&blq_identity=off\&blq_language=en-gb\&blq_footer_link_text_1=News Sources\&blq_footer_link_url_1=/news/1/hi/help/3281815.stm\&blq_footer_link_text_2=About BBC News\&blq_footer_link_url_2=/news/1/hi/help/default.stm\&blq_footer_link_text_3=\&blq_footer_link_url_3=\&identity_target_resource=http://identity/policies/dna/adult\&blq_footer_color=transparent\&IP_IS_ADVERTISE_COMBINED=yes\&IP_IS_UK_COMBINED=no\&ADS_ENABLED=\&COUNTRY=us\&blq_cachebust_journalism=1.21.9\&blq_journalism_variant=1\&blq_promo_optout=1\&blq_gvl=3.5\&blq_contact_us_url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/newswatch/ifs/hi/feedback/default.stm\&blq_mobile_url=/news/mobile/\&bbcpage_survey=off\&bbcpage_surveysite=\&bbcpage_survey_nopop=\&survey_forceon=\&blq_doctype=xhtml+rdfa\&blq_footer_color=transparent\&blq_masthead_opacity=40\&blq_search_scope=news\&blq_nedstat=1\&blq_requirejs=on\&blq_variant=\&blq_istats_linktracking=true\&blq_masthead_background=transparent-light
bbc_fmtj_net_json_module_loaded=True
site=news
section=Business
ADS_ENABLED=yes
HOST_IS_ALLOWED=yes
BBCCOM_CLIENT_SIDE_DELIVERY=no
bbcdotcom_showadverts=yes
bbcdotcom_showfooter=yes
bddUseLatestFromTest=false
MASTHEAD=yes
PAL_NEWS_STATIC_VERSION=1.4.3-477
PAL_NEWS_SERVER_ENV=live
PAL_NEWS_STATIC_HOST=static.bbci.co.uk
PAL_NEWS_STATIC_PATH=http://static.bbci.co.uk/news/1.4.3-477
PAL_NEWS_POLLING_HOST=http://polling.bbc.co.uk
PAL_NEWS_PATH_PREFIX=http://www.live.bbc.co.uk/nfp
PAL_NEWS_SERVER_HOST=http://www.live.bbc.co.uk
NEWS_WEATHER_FLAGPOLE=true
DNA_HOST_PREFIX=http://feeds.bbci.co.uk
ENABLE_INDEX_COMMENT_COUNTS=true
CDN_REQUEST=false
blq_nedstat_url_cdata=//sa.bbc.co.uk/bbc/bbc/s?name=news.business.story.21038128.page&cps_asset_id=21038128&page_type=story&section=business&app_version=6.2.120-RC3&first_pub=2013-01-16T00:57:10+00:00&last_editorial_update=2013-01-16T07:17:36+00:00&title=Japan+emergency+hits+Dreamliners&comments_box=false&cps_media_type=&cps_media_state=&app_type=web&ml_name=SSI&ml_version=0.14.4&language=en-GB
blq_nedstat_url_no_script=//sa.bbc.co.uk/bbc/bbc/s?name=news.business.story.21038128.page&cps_asset_id=21038128&page_type=story&section=business&app_version=6.2.120-RC3&first_pub=2013-01-16T00:57:10+00:00&last_editorial_update=2013-01-16T07:17:36+00:00&title=Japan+emergency+hits+Dreamliners&comments_box=false&cps_media_type=&cps_media_state=&app_type=web&ml_name=SSI&ml_version=0.14.4&language=en-GB
CPS_SHOW_ADVERTISING=yes
BBCCOM_RIGHTSBLOCK=no
BBCCOM_MEDIAID=17821687
emp_id=emp-17821687-46901
DISPLAY_PROGRAMMES_HEADER_FOR_CPS_OUTPUT=true