Panel Review Binder

Outcome Assessment Plan

1. Review Panel Binder Table of Contents
2. Agenda
3. Roster
4. Questions to be Answered by Panel
   1. Global Assessment Questions
   2. Individual Grant Assessment Questions
5. RFA-GM-99-007, Large-Scale Collaborative Project Awards
6. Conception and Management of Glue Grants - Presentation by Dr. Michael Rogers
7. Basic Administrative Information on Awarded Grants
8. Letter from Dr. Jeremy Berg to Glue Grant Principal Investigators
   Attachment – Information Requested from PIs
   
   Information Requested from Investigators (not included in report)
   
   
9. Information Requested from Investigators
   1. Alliance for Cellular Signaling (Dr. Rochelle Long)
   2. Cell Migration Consortium (Dr. Alan “Rick” Horwitz)
   3. Consortium for Functional Glycomics (Dr. James Paulson)
   4. Inflammation and the Host Response to Injury (Dr. Ronald Tompkins)
   5. Lipid MAPS (Dr. Edward Dennis)

   Information provided by Nature (not included in report)

10. Nature Gateway Data
    1. Structural Biology Knowledgebase Analytics Report for calibration on the issues
    2. Signaling Gateway Data
    3. Cell Migration Consortium Gateway Data
    4. Consortium for Functional Glycomics Gateway Data
    5. Lipid MAPS Gateway Data

    Preliminary report at meeting.Final Report linked from main report page.

11. Summary of Objective Data – Bibliometric analysis by Discovery Logic/Thomson Reuters

    Report linked from main report page.

12. Summary of Community Input Responses – Analysis by Ripple Effect Communications, Inc.

    Previous Evaluations and Management Reports

13. Glue Grant Process Evaluation Report – Linked on glue grant Web site.
14. NIGMS Response to Evaluation Report – Linked on glue grant Web site.

    The following materials are considered privileged communications and are not included in the Outcomes Assessment Report.

15. Reports from most recent glue grant interim progress reviews by other expert panels
    1. Cell Migration Consortium – Administrative Review
    2. Consortium for Functional Glycomics – Administrative Review
16. NIGMS program official and scientific liaison opinions
    1. Alliance for Cellular Signaling (Dr. Rochelle Long)
    2. Cell Migration Consortium (Dr. James Deatherage)
    3. Consortium for Functional Glycomics (Dr. Pamela Marino)
    4. Inflammation and the Host Response to Injury (Dr. Scott Somers)
    5. Lipid MAPS (Dr. Jean Chin and Dr. Bert Shapiro)