ASSISTIVE LISTENING SYSTEMS
WHY AN ASSISTIVE LISTENING SYSTEM?
Background noise and reverberation degrade intelligibility much faster for individuals who are
deaf or hard of hearing, whether they wear hearing aids or not. Thus, deaf and hard of hearing
people are prevented from participating on equal terms with normal hearing people in public
accommodations such as conference rooms, auditoriums, theaters, museums, theme parks, and
sports arenas which are not equipped with assistive listening systems. Even the best in sound
systems technology combined with the best in hearing aid technology cannot solve the
intelligibility problems faced by people who are deaf or hard of hearing. In recognition of this,
requirements for installation of assistive listening devices in places of public accommodation were
included in the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) signed into law in July of 1990.
The purpose of an assistive listening system is to transmit the sound as directly as possible to the deaf or hard of hearing person's ear. Such systems should not be confused with audio systems (eg. PA systems) generally designed to enhance the sound quality for people without hearing aids. There are three basic wireless technologies available today which provide different methods of meeting the requirements: Induction loop technology, FM broadcast technology, and infrared light technology. No single technology is best for all applications. All three types of assistive listening systems can be easily and successfully installed in new and old facilities alike, as long as their individual limitations are kept in mind. Without attempting to tie the various technologies to specific applications, some of their relative advantages and limitations can be found on the comparison chart on the next page. Note: Manufacturers of the various technologies may carry product lines which range in price as well as applicability. It is important to recognize that each model of audio loop, FM, or infrared equipment may have specific advantages and disadvantages which are not necessarily reflected on the chart.
INDUCTION LOOP TECHNOLOGY. This technology is based on electromagnetic transmission and has the unique advantage that the signal is received directly by the user's hearing aid when it is equipped with a telecoil circuit or "T" switch without the need for an additional receiver as is required by all other technologies. However, if the listener does not have a hearing aid equipped with a telecoil, nor has a hearing aid at all, then induction receivers must be used. There are three types. The first two are most common: (1) A wand-like device; (2) a pocket-sized device with headphones; (3) A telecoil installed inside a plastic shell which looks like but is not a hearing aid.
FM BROADCAST TECHNOLOGY. FM systems operate at FCC designated frequencies.
Since each system may use its own broadcast frequency, several systems may operate
simultaneously at one location without interfering with one another. However, unlike the loop
system, the FM system requires a special receiver for each person, whether s/he has a hearing aid
or not. Several options for coupling a hearing aid to an FM system are available. The most
convenient for public places consists of either a neckloop or a silhouette inductor(s) which is used
with the hearing aid's telecoil circuit.
INFRARED LIGHT TECHNOLOGY. From a practical point of view, the infrared receiver
system is in many ways similar in operation to the FM system. However, receivers must be in line-of-sight of the emitter (transmitter) therefore the signal can only be received inside the covered
room. As with FM technology, each person must use a receiver, whether or not s/he has a
hearing aid. The same options for coupling the infrared receiver to the hearing aid exist as for FM
systems.
COMPARISON OF LARGE AREA ASSISTIVE LISTENING SYSTEMS
System Description | Advantages | Disadvantages | Typical Applications |
FM BROADCAST (72-76 MHz)
(40 frequencies available on narrow band transmission
systems. Ten frequencies
available on wideband
transmission systems.)
Transmitters: FM base station or personal transmitter
broadcasts signal to
listening area.
Receiver: Pocket size with a) earphone(s), or b) headset, or c) induction neck-loop or silhouette coil coupling to personal hearing aid equipped with T-coil, or d) direct audio input (DAI) to personal hearing aid. |
Highly portable when
used with body-worn,
personal transmitter.
Easy to install. May be used separately or integrated with existing PA-systems. Multiple frequencies allow for use by different groups within same area (eg. multi-language translation). |
Signal spill-over to
adjacent rooms/listening
areas (can prevent
interference
by using different transmission frequencies for each room/listening area). Choose infrared if privacy is essential. Receivers required for everyone/ requires administration and maintenance of receivers. Susceptible to electrical interference when used with induction neck-loop/silhouette (DAI impractical for public applications). Some systems more susceptible to radio wave interference and signal drift than others. |
Service counters
Outdoor guided tours Tour busses Meeting rooms Conference rooms Auditoriums Classrooms Courtrooms Churches and Temples Theaters Museums Theme parks Arenas Sport stadiums Retirement/nursing homes Hospitals |
INFRARED LIGHT
Transmitter: Amplifier drives emitter panel(s) covering listening area. Receivers: Under-chin or Pendant type receiver with a) headset, or b) earphone(s), or c) induction neck-loop or silhouette coil coupling to personal hearing aid equipped with T-coil, or d) direct audio input (DAI) to personal hearing aid. |
No spillover to adjacent
rooms, etc. Insures
confidentiality (Unlike
induction or FM
transmission, IR
transmission does not
travel through walls or
other solid surfaces).
Infrared receivers compatible with most infrared emitters. May be used separately or integrated with existing PA-systems. Can be used for multi-language translation (must use special multi-frequency receivers). |
Receivers required for
everyone/
requires administration and maintenance of receivers. Ineffective in direct sunlight. Carefull installation required to insure entire listening area will receive IR signal. Susceptible to electrical interference when used with induction neckloop/silhouette (DAI impractical for public applications). Lifetime of emitters varies w/ company. Historical buildings may pose installation problem (some sites will not allow visible emitters). |
Indoor service counters
Meetings requiring confidentiality Meeting rooms Conference rooms Auditoriums Classrooms Courtrooms Churches and Temples Theaters Museums Arenas (indoors only) Sport stadiums (indoors only) Retirement/nursing homes Hospitals |
Continued on next page |
COMPARISON OF LARGE AREA ASSISTIVE LISTENING SYSTEMS
System Description | Advantages | Disadvantages | Typical Applications |
CONVENTIONAL INDUCTION
LOOP
Transmitter: Amplifier drives an induction loop that surrounds listening area. Receivers: 1) Personal hearing aid with T-coil. 2) Pocket size induction receiver with earphone or headset. 3) Self-contained wand. 4) Telecoil inside plastic chassis which looks like a BTE, ITE, or canal hearing aid. |
Requires little, or
no administration of
receivers, provided
most people have
telecoil-equipped
hearing aids.
Induction receivers are compatible with all loop systems. Unobtrusive w/ T-coil hearing aid. May be used separately or integrated with existing PA-systems. Some available with level AGC to compensate for varying voice levels and/or distance to mic. Portable systems are available for use with small groups of listeners. These portable systems can be stored in a carrying case and set up temporarily, as needed. |
Signal spill-over to
adjacent rooms.
Susceptible to electrical interference. Limited portability unless areas are pre-looped or small, portable system is used (see advantages). Requires installation of loop wire. Installation may be difficult in pre-existing buildings. Skilled installation essential in historical buildings (and may not be permitted at all). If listener does not have telecoil-equipped hearing aid (cannot assume everyone does), then requires administration and maintenance of receivers. |
Service counters
Ports of transportation Public transportation vehicles Tour busses Meeting rooms Conference rooms Auditoriums Classrooms Courtrooms Churches and Temples Theaters Museums Theme parks Arenas Sport stadiums Retirement/nursing homes Hospitals |
3-D LOOP
SYSTEM
Transmitter: Amplifier drives a 3-D mat that is placed under the carpet of the listening area. Receivers: 1) Personal hearing aid with T-coil. 2) Pocket size induction receiver with earphone or headset. 3) Self-contained wand. 4) Telecoil inside
plastic chassis which
looks like a BTE,
ITE, or canal
hearing aid.
|
Requires little, or
no administration of
receivers, provided
most people have
telecoil-equipped
hearing aids.
Induction receivers are compatible with all loops systems. May be used separately or integrated with existing PA-systems. Three-dimensional reception of loop signal regardless of telecoil position. Reduced signal spillover allows adjacent rooms to be looped without signal interference. 3-D loop mats must be separated by 6 feet to avoid signal spillover. |
Limited portability
(areas may be pre-3-D Loop matted to
facilitate portability).
Requires installation of 3-D Loop mats. Installation may be difficult in pre-existing buildings. Skilled installation essential in historical buildings (and may not be permitted at all). If listener does not have telecoil-equipped hearing aid (cannot assume everyone does), then requires administration and maintenance of receivers. Susceptible to electrical interference. |
Service counters
Ports of Transportation Meeting rooms Conference rooms Auditoriums Class rooms Court rooms Museums Theme Parks Retirement/nursing homes Meetings requiring confidentiality Hospitals |
Modified from a chart published by Centrum Sound, Cupertino, California
Cynthia L. Compton, Assistive Devices Center, Department of Audiology and Speech-Language Pathology Gallaudet University, Washington, DC |