Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.
--- Voltaire
Public sentiment is everything. With public sentiment nothing can fail; without it nothing can succeed. He who molds public sentiment goes deeper than he who
enacts statutes or pronounces decisions. He makes statutes or decisions possible or impossible to execute.
--- President Abraham Lincoln
One cannot wage war under present conditions without the support of public opinion, which is tremendously molded by the press and other forms of propaganda.
--- General Douglas MacArthur
The printing press is the greatest weapon in the armoury of the modern commander.... In Asia we were so weak physically that we could not let the metaphysical weapon rust unused.
--- T.E. Lawrence
U.S. Government Funded
- Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG)
- Voice of America (VoA), programming in over 50 languages
Adhering to the principles outlined in the [VOA] Charter, VOA reporters and broadcasters must strive for accuracy and objectivity in all their work. They do not speak for the U.S. government. They accept no treatment or assistance from U.S. government officials or agencies that is more favorable or less favorable than that granted to staff of private-sector news agencies.
- Radio Sawa, Arabic broadcasts throughout Middle East
Radio Sawa is a service of U.S. International Broadcasting, which is operated and funded by the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), an agency of the U.S. Government. The BBG serves as a firewall to protect the professional independence and integrity of the broadcasters.
- Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, including broadcasts in at least 27 languages throughout Central and Southwest Asia
Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty is a private, international communications service to Eastern and Southeastern Europe, Russia, the Caucasus, Central Asia, and the Middle East, funded by the United States Congress.
- Radio Free Asia, broadcasting in Eastern Asia in at least nine languages
None of our staff are government employees. And I am proud to say we live by rigid standards of journalistic objectivity. Our job: quite simply, to bring news and information about their own country to populations denied the benefits of freedom of information by their governments.
- Radio / TV Marti, broadcasts to Cuba
En el mantenimiento de los principios establecidos por la legislación que creó a La Voz de América, VOA , ambas estaciones transmiten noticias e informaciones verídicas y objetivas sobre temas de interés para el pueblo de Cuba.
- Worldnet Television, broadcasting over the Internet - including African Journal, Latin American programming, Eastern Europe programming, and more -- merged with VoA in May 2004.
- Bureau of International Information Programs (IIP), State Department
DoD/Joint Resources
- Defense Media Activity (DMA)
- The Department of Defense (DoD) is undertaking an initiative designed to modernize and streamline media operations by consolidating military Service and DoD media components into a single, integrated and transformed organization, the Defense Media Activity (DMA).
- DOD beefing up public affairs staff; quick response is among goals, by Schogol, in Stars & Stripes, 1 Nov 06
- Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs - OASD (PA)
- New "JPASE" sets the pace for joint military public affairs, JFCOM news release, 18 Jan 2006 - Joint Public Affairs Support Element (JPASE) scheduled for full operation in April 2006
- The Joint Public Affairs Support Element (JPASE) supported joint task force commanders dealing with the aftermaths of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita as well as October's earthquake in Pakistan.
- As part of its deployment functions, JPASE provides a constant flow of timely, accurate information from combatant commanders to news organizations that set up camp wherever American forces operate.
- The speed of the Internet, cable news and other media all contribute to rapid shaping of public opinion of military operations. Armed forces public affairs personnel and their communication skills are indispensable to meeting this challenging information environment, according to military leaders.
- Preventing misinformation and setting up media access while initial public impressions are forming has been a formidable challenge for the Department of Defense, until now, according to JPASE Director Army Col. Steve Campbell.
- Defense Information School (DINFOS) "The DINFOS mission is to train military and civilian personnel within DoD, other Federal agencies, and selected foreign nations in Public Affairs and Visual Information career fields."
- American Forces Radio and Television Service (AFRTS) "The AFRTS mission is to communicate Department of Defense policies, priorities, programs, goals and initiatives. AFRTS provides stateside radio and television programming, "a touch of home," to U.S. service men and women, DoD civilians, and their families serving outside the continental United States."
- DoD Joint Course in Communication (DoDJCC) - especially check out the CAPSTONE projects on perceived ethics, communications in a variety of contexts, and deception
- DoD Documents
- DoD Directive 5122.05, Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs (ASD(PA)), 5 Sep 2008 (Local copy) which includes
- Enclosure 3 - the Statement of DoD Principles for News Media Coverage of DoD Operations
aka the Nine Principles of Combat Coverage
- 1. Open and independent reporting shall be the principal means of coverage of U.S. military operations.
- 2. Media pools (limited number of news media who represent a larger number of news media organizations for news gatherings and sharing of material during a specified activity) are not to serve as the standard means of covering U.S. military operations. However, they sometimes may provide the only means of early access to a military operation. In this case, media pools should be as large as possible and disbanded at the earliest opportunity (in 24 to 36 hours, when
possible). The arrival of early-access media pools shall not cancel the principle of independent coverage for journalists already in the area.
- 3. Even under conditions of open coverage, pools may be applicable for specific events, such as those at extremely remote locations or where space is limited.
- 4. Journalists in a combat zone shall be credentialed by the U.S. military and shall be required to abide by a clear set of military security ground rules that protect U.S. Armed Forces and their operations. Violation of the ground rules may result in suspension of credentials and expulsion from the combat zone of the journalist involved. News organizations shall make their best efforts to assign experienced journalists to combat operations and to make them familiar with
U.S. military operations.
- 5. Journalists shall be provided access to all major military units. Special operations restrictions may limit access in some cases.
- 6. Military PA officers should act as liaisons, but should not interfere with the reporting process.
- 7. Under conditions of open coverage, field commanders should be instructed to permit journalists to ride on military vehicles and aircraft when possible. The military shall be responsible for the transportation of pools.
- 8. Consistent with its capabilities, the military shall supply PA officers with facilities to enable timely, secure, compatible transmission of pool material and shall make those facilities available, when possible, for filing independent coverage. If Government facilities are unavailable, journalists, as always, shall file by any other means available. The military shall not ban communications systems operated by news organizations, but electromagnetic operational security in battlefield situations may require limited restrictions on the use of such systems.
- 9. Those principles in paragraph 8 shall apply as well to the operations of the standing DoD National Media Pool system.
- DODD 5230.09, Clearance of DoD Information for Public Release (Local copy)
- DODD 5230.16, Nuclear Accident and Incident Public Affairs Guidance (Local copy)
- DODD 5400.13, Public Affairs (PA) Operations (Local copy)
- DODD 5410.14, Cooperation with U.S. News Media Representatives at the Scene of Military Accidents Occurring Outside Military Installations (Local copy)
- Public Affairs Guidance (PAG) on Embedding Media During Possible Future Operations/Deployments in the U.S. Central Command's (CENTCOM) Area of Responsibility (AOR) (local copy), 10 Feb 2003
- Joint Pubs
- Early Bird, current news
Army, Navy, and Marines
- Army
- Army Public Affairs Center (APAC)
- Army Broadcasting Service (ABS)
- Army & Air Force Hometown News Service
- Media Relations: Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (local copy), CALL Newsletter 09-11, Dec 08
- This newsletter makes the case for changing public relations and media relations to support contemporary operations, especially in a counterinsurgency environment. It explains why commanders, not just the public affairs office, must be involved in public affairs (PA) operations.
- Media Is the Battlefield: Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (local copy), CALL Newsletter 07-04, Oct 06
- Media operations are vital components of the information operations fight. This newsletter explores the role media operations play on the modern battlefield, enumerating battle-tested and proven public affairs training guidance tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTP). These TTP help units and Soldiers gain a better perspective and situational understanding of the battlefield environment. Media operations provide units and Soldiers with an enhanced capability to view
the adversary and themselves through someone else’s viewpoint – via television, Internet, or print media.
- In the Spotlight: Media and the Tactical Commander, CALL Newsletter 92-7
- As we observed during Operations DESERT SHIELD and DESERT STORM, the media will be present on any future battlefields. We also became aware how the media play a major role in keeping soldiers and family members informed and, to a great extent, how the American and world public perceive the operation. In World War II, Korea and even Vietnam, news did not normally reach the public or the soldiers until it was at least 24 hours old. But today's technology allows the media a high degree of mobility and the ability to transmit their stories and images instantly. Technology also allows soldiers access to the media's products, right along with the rest of the world. Because of this technology, real-life media support and encounter training should be incorporated into battalion, brigade, division, and corps field training and command post exercises. Also, battlefield media play should become a routine part of the scenarios at the combat training centers.
- Meeting the Media - A Guide to Encountering the Media (local copy),
U.S. Army Training and Doctrine Command's Pocket Guide to Encountering the Media
- FM 3-61.1, Public Affairs Tactics, Techniques and Procedures
- FM 3-13, Information Operations - Doctrine, Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures supercedes FM 100-6
- FM 46-1, Public Affairs Operations
- ArmyLINK News
- Soldiers Magazine Online
- Golden Knights, U.S. Army Parachute Team
- Guide to making movies with the Army - getting permissions, assistance, and advice
- Installation Media Relations Operations (local copy), from the Center for Army Lessons Learned
- Navy
- Marines
Air Force Resources
9-11 and After, Media Coverage
Media Relations, including Wartime Coverage
- See also Public Affairs Forum, USAF Counterproliferation Center
- See DoD's Nine Principles of Combat Coverage
- See being interviewed by the media
- The Military-Media Relationship: A Dysfunctional Marriage? (local copy), by Shanker and Hertling, in Military Review, Sep-Oct 2009
- Misfortunes of War: Press and Public Reactions to Civilian Deaths in Wartime,by Larson and Savych, RAND report, 2006
- Press Pools, Prior Restraint
and the Persian Gulf War, by Mordan, in Air & Space Power Chronicles
see especially the references in the Notes section
- Military-Media Relations, 1848-2001, quick overview of coverage, numbers of correspondents, and level of censoring
- "No Bad Stories" - the American Media-Military Relationship (local copy), by Porch, in Naval War College Review, Winter 2002 - covering the period from the American Revolution to Kosovo
- DoD Guides for Interacting with Media
- Public Affairs Guidance (PAG) on Embedding Media During Possible Future Operations/Deployments in the U.S. Central Command's (CENTCOM) Area of Responsibility (AOR) (local copy), 10 Feb 2003
- DoD Joint Course in Communication, University of Oklahoma
- Covering News in Wartime, tools and guides for covering war, from the Project for Excellence in Journalism, Columbia U. Graduate School of Journalism
- "No Bad Stories" - the American Media-Military Relationship (local copy), by Porch, in Naval War College Review, Winter 2002
- Reporters on the Ground: the Military and the Media's Joint Experience During Operation Iraqi Freedom (local copy), Oct 2003 issue paper, Center for Strategic Leadership
- 30 Oct 2002 - Pentagon announced it will begin offering special training--including instruction on chemical weapons protection--to journalists who cover the military.
- The Enemies from Within, by Hackworth, 14 Aug 2002
If George W. Bush gives the order to take out Iraq's Root of Much Evil, at least a platoon of newspaper reporters, editors and publishers -- Palm Pilots at high port -- should be leading the charge in the first wave on D-Day. It seems only fair that the finks who couldn't give Saddam our battle plans fast enough should serve as point men.
- The Reasons Behind a White House Rebuke, Washington Post, 24 June 2002
In fact, intercepting bin Laden's satellite and other phone conversations has been publicized since 1998, Fleischer said. He cited the revelation then that the United States could monitor bin Laden's use of a satellite phone and therefore know his whereabouts.
Intelligence officials said bin Laden stopped using the phone after the information became known, calling it a major intelligence setback.
- "Access Denied: The Pentagon's War Reporting Rules are the Toughest Ever," by Hickey, in the Columbia Journalism Review
- Military Review, Jan-Feb 2002
- Seminar on Coverage of the War on Terrorism (local copy), co-sponsored by the Brookings Institution, posted by DoD on 16 Nov 01
- The Impact of Media Information on Enemy Effectiveness: a Model for Conflict (local copy, 421 Kb), published in Proteus, used here by permission of the authors
- The Military Vision Leader in the New Millenium - An Essay on the Concept of Strategic Image (local copy), by Lt Col Mike Ritz
- The Military and the Media: One Man's Experience (local copy), by Joe Galloway, Senior Writer, U.S. News & World Report, recounting experiences from Ia Drang Valley in Vietnam, to the Gulf War -- and the need for understanding by both sides -- EXCELLENT READ
- Soldiers and Scribblers Revisited: Working with the Media (local copy), by Richard Halloran, Originally published in Army War College's Parameters
- The Military and the Media - Toward a Strategy of Engagement and Enlargement (local copy), by Col Thomas Hall
- Military-Media Relations in Recent U.S. Operations (local copy), by Bruner, U.S. Army Management Staff College, 1997
- - includes examination of operations in Grenada, Panama, Gulf War, and Haiti
- - includes recommendations from various panels and conferences
- Press Coverage in Somalia: A Case for Media Relations to be a Principle of Operations Other Than War (local copy), by Stockwell, Command and Staff College, 1995
- The Military/Media Clash and the New Principle of War: Media Spin (local copy), by Felman, SAAS, 1992 - examines media impact from Vietnam to Gulf War
- Winning CNN Wars (local copy), by Stech, in Parameters, Autumn 1994
- The Military-News Media Relationship: Thinking Forward (local copy), by Ricks, SSI, 1993
- Public Affairs Focused Issue of Military Review, Dec-Feb 1998-1999
- First Amendment stuff at Freedom Forum Online
- America's Team: The Odd Couple - A Report on the Relationship Between the Media and the Military, by Aukofer and Lawrence - 4.7 Mb PDF file
Embedded Media
- Twenty-First Century Embedded Journalists: Lawful Targets? (local copy), by Moore, in The Army Lawyer, July 2009 - includes extensive history of press-mililtary relationship, and appendices include numbers of media in various recent conflicts - excellent footnotes and references
- Reporters on the Battlefield: The Embedded Press System in Historical Context, by James and Kim, RAND, 2004
- Reporting from the Sandstorm: An Appraisal of Embedding (local copy), by McLane, in Parameters, Spring 2004
- Perspectives on Embedded Media (local copy), selected papers from Army War College
- Leveraging the Media: the Embedded Media Program in Operation Iraqi Freedom (local copy), July 2004 issue paper, Center for Strategic Leadership
- Reporters on the Ground: the Military and the Media's Joint Experience During Operation Iraqi Freedom (local copy), Oct 2003 issue paper, Center for Strategic Leadership
- The Army and Embedded Media (local copy), by Miracle, in Military Review, Sep-Oct 2003
- Defining News in the Middle East, Terence Smith grades the war coverage, in May/June 2003 Columbia Journalism Review
- "Gulf War II, the real-time war, it seems, has so far posed more questions for news organizations than it has answered."
- Embedded Reporters: What Are Americans Getting?, 3 Apr 2003 research paper from Project for Excellence in Journalism, Columbia U. Graduate School of Journalism
- TV Combat Fatigue on the Rise But 'Embeds' Viewed Favorably, 28 Mar 2003, Pew Research Center
- "Wall-to-wall media reports on the war in Iraq have not resulted in significant improvement in the public's view of the media's coverage of this war compared with the first Persian Gulf conflict. However, there are signs that 24-7 televised images of war are taking an increasing psychological toll. In recent days, more than four-in-ten (42%) expressed the view that "It tires me out to watch" TV coverage of the war, up from about one-in-three who agreed with that statement in the early days of the conflict."
- Press, military laud embedded media (local copy), by Garamone, 26 Mar 2003, American Forces Press Service
- Media Becomes Part of the Team in Deployments (local copy), CENTCOM News, 08 Mar 03
- 27 Feb 2003 ASD PA Clarke meeting with bureau chiefs (local copy), embedded program ("air" embeds and others) discussed
- Public Affairs Guidance (PAG) on Embedding Media During Possible Future Operations/Deployments in the U.S. Central Command's (CENTCOM) Area of Responsibility (AOR) (local copy), 10 Feb 2003
- "This message provides guidance, policies and procedures on embedding news media during possible future operations/deployments in the CENTCOM AOR. It can be adapted for use in other unified command AORs as necessary."
- 30 Oct 2002 - Pentagon announced it will begin offering special training--including instruction on chemical weapons protection--to journalists who cover the military.
Media as Instrument of War
- The printing press is the greatest weapon in the armoury of the modern commander
--- T.E. Lawrence
- YouTube War: Fighting in a World of Cameras in Every Cell Phone and Photoshop on Every Computer (local copy), by Dauber, Strategic Studies Institute, Nov 2009
- Rumsfeld speech to Council on Foreign Relations (local copy), 17 Feb 06, DoD transcript
- We meet today in the sixth year in which our nation has been engaged in what promises to be a long struggle against an enemy that in many ways is unlike any our country has ever faced. And in this war, some of the most critical battles may not be in the mountains of Afghanistan or the streets of Iraq, but in newsrooms -- in places like New York, London, Cairo, and elsewhere.
- I mention this because I want to talk today about something that at first might seem obvious -- but it isn’t. Our enemies have skillfully adapted to fighting wars in today’s media age, but for the most part we -- our country -- has not -- whether our government, the media or our society generally.
- Consider that the violent extremist have established “media relations committees” -- and have proven to be highly successful at manipulating opinion elites. They plan and design their headline-grabbing attacks using every means of communications to intimidate and break the collective will of free people.
- They know that communications transcend borders -- and that a single news story, handled skillfully, can be as damaging to our cause and as helpful to theirs, as any other method of military attack. And they are doing it.
- They are able to act quickly with relatively few people, and with modest resources compared to the vast -- and expensive -- bureaucracies of western governments.
- Our federal government is only beginning to adapt our operations for the 21st Century. For the most part, the U.S. Government still functions as a “five and dime” store in an E-Bay world.
- We must get a great deal better at:
- Engaging experts from both within and outside of government to help to communicate;
- Rapidly deploying the best military communications capabilities to new theaters of operation; and
- Developing and executing multifaceted media campaigns -- print, radio, television and Internet.
- Let there be no doubt -- the longer it takes to put a strategic communications framework into place, the more we can be certain that the vacuum will be filled by the enemy and by news informers, that most assuredly will not paint an accurate picture of what is actually taking place.
- The Media as an Instrument of War, by Payne, in Parameters, Spring 2005
- Ralph Peters, “Kill Faster,” New York Post, 20 May 2004
- "The [US] Marines in Fallujah weren’t beaten by the terrorists and insurgents, who were being eliminated effectively and accurately. They were beaten by al-Jazeera.... The media [are] often referred to off-handedly as a strategic factor. But we still don’t fully appreciate [their] fatal power...."
- The Future Military-Media Relationship: the Media As an Actor in War Execution, by Hill, ACSC, 1997
- Mass Media: the Tenth Principle of War? (local copy), by Squire, Naval War College, 1995
- Democracy and Protracted War: the Impact of Television, by Venanzi, in Air University Review, Jan-Feb 1983
Media & the Military in History
- I hate newspapermen. They come into camp and pick up their camp rumors and print them as facts. I regard them as spies, which in truth, they are. If I killed them all there would be news from Hell before breakfast
--- General William Tecumseh Sherman
- Seeing through the Conflict: Military-Media Relations (local copy), by Snyder, US Army War College, 2003
- The Military and the Media: One Man's Experience (local copy), by Joe Galloway, Senior Writer, U.S. News & World Report, recounting experiences from Ia Drang Valley in Vietnam, to the Gulf War -- and the need for understanding by both sides -- EXCELLENT READ
- "No Bad Stories" - the American Media-Military Relationship (local copy), by Porch, in Naval War College Review, Winter 2002 - covering the period from the American Revolution to Kosovo
- The Media and the Military: an Historical and Cultural Examination, by Hannon, AFIT, 1998
- Military-Media Relations, 1848-2001, quick overview of coverage, numbers of correspondents, and level of censoring
Wartime Reporting, the Correspondents
- See also media and reporting
- See also embed program and results
- The Military and the Media: One Man's Experience (local copy), by Joe Galloway, Senior Writer, U.S. News & World Report, recounting experiences from Ia Drang Valley in Vietnam, to the Gulf War -- and the need for understanding by both sides -- EXCELLENT READ
- Martha Gellhorn: War Reporter, D-Day Stowaway (Local Copy), by Kozaryn, for American Forces Press Service, 6 Mar 1998
In 1937, the Spanish Civil War sparked Gellhorn's career as a war correspondent. Encouraged by second husband Ernest Hemingway, she submitted an article about the war to Collier's Weekly magazine.
From then on, her work took her to the front lines of the Sino-Japanese conflict, to the blackouts and bombings of World War II London, and to the ravaged landscape of Nazi Germany. Without official press credentials, she reached the beaches of Normandy on D-Day as a stretcher bearer after hiding in the lavatory of a hospital ship.
- Reporting America at War, PBS special, features Pyle, Morrow, and others
- The Death of Captain Waskow, one of Ernie Pyle's most widely remembered columns
- Other columns by Ernie Pyle
- War Is A Force That Gives Us Meaning, interview with Chris Hedges, author of the book by the same title
- Edward R. Murrow's Report From Buchenwald
- The women who wrote the war (WW II), Online NewsHour, PBS
- "The Writing 69th" home page
- Covering the War (Vietnam), its effects on journalism, Online NewsHour, PBS
- War Stories, Newseum, interviews with correspondents
Media in New and Emerging Democracies
- If it were left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.
--- Thomas Jefferson
- Center for Democracy and Governance, USAID web site with handbooks, studies, etc.
- Building Free and Independent Media (Local Copy), Freedom Paper No. 1, USINFO, State Dept
- Media & Democracy, by George Krimsky
- Use and Abuse of Media in Vulnerable Societies, report from U.S. Institute of Peace (USIP)
- The Media and the Marginalized: Observations of an Outsider, by James A. Joseph
- Changing Channels: Free Press in Emerging Democracies, USAID transcript of video
Media and Terrorism
- Iraqi Insurgent Media: the War of Images and Ideas - How Sunni Insurgents in Iraq and Their Supporters Worldwide are Using the Media, by Kimmage and Ridolfo, RFE/RL Special Report, 2007
- Cerberus to Mind: Media as Sentinel in the Fight against Terrorism, by Bowdish, Strategic Insights, Volume V, Issue 5 (May 2006)
- "At the dawn of the 21st Century, Cerberus sleeps at the gates of the global media. All the while, terrorists pass their messages of influence against a mentally unguarded public. Terrorists influence the will of the people through the manipulation of terror, spread through the leverage of the global media. Lest the government turn to the beast of “censorship,” the media must voluntarily take on guardianship at the gates to the mind."
- "... the tremendous leverage that results from the synergy of coupling physical acts of violence with the mass media to achieve psychological impact against populations numbering orders of magnitude greater than the immediate participants."
- Enduring the Media, war on terrorism coverage, articles posted at Media Research Center
- Terrorism, the Media, and the Government: Perspectives, Trends, and Options for Policymakers(local copy), by Perl, for Congressional Research Service -- including discussion of what each party hopes to get out of press coverage of terrorism
- The Al-Jazeera News Network: Opportunity or Challenge for U.S. Foreign Policy in the Middle East? (Local copy), Congressional Research Service report
- Terrorism & the Domestic "War on Terror", resources at FAIR
- Accomplice or Witness? The Media's Role in Terrorism, by Nacos, April 2000 issue of Current History
- Muslims caught in the crossfire - comments about the impact of the coverage of Muslim terrorists
- How the Community May Be Affected by Media Coverage of the Terrorist Attack, National Center for PTSD
- Terrorism and the Media - Are Terrorists interested in publicity, in Terrorism: Questions & Answers, Council on Foreign Relations
Media Guides & DoD Assistance
- see also DoD support to Hollywood, at Cyberspace & Information Operations Study Center
- Handbook of Independent Journalism (Local Copy), by Potter, for the Bureau of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State, 2006
- A Responsible Press Office: An Insiders Guide (Local Copy), by Sullivan, for the Bureau of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State, Sep 2001
- CDC Media Relations
- George Washington University Online Media Guide, and example of an organization's online representation to the press and the public
- Media Guide, Univ. of Calif. Irvine, including interviews and crisis interaction with the press
Media Agenda Setting
- See CNN Effect section below
- Agenda Setting Bibliography
- Media Agenda Setting, Northern Illinois University
- The Gulf War: A Study of the Media, Public Opinion, and Public Knowledge, U. of Mass. Center for the Study of Communication -- including study of the paradox that it seems the more information is available to the public, the less they seem to understand about what's really going on
- Beyond Agenda Setting: The Media's Power to Prime, by Morgan, Middle Tennessee State University - first paragraph below
- Though early studies in communications science concluded that the media had minimal effects on public thinking, agenda-setting theory was one of the first moves toward a more powerful effects model of communications. Agenda setting, a term coined by McCombs and Shaw in a 1972 study, shows a correspondence between the order of importance given in the media to issues and the order of significance attached to the same issues by the public and politicians (McQuail, 1994, p. 256). Through repeated news coverage, agenda setting suggests that the media have the capability to raise the importance of certain issues in the public's mind (Severin & Tankard, 1997, p. 249). This theory further supports a statement made by Cohen (1963) that the news media may not directly affect how the public thinks about political matters, but it does affect what subjects people think about. In short, it sets the agenda for what political matters people consider important (Severin & Tankard, 1997, p. 252).
- Media and the Social Agenda, one segment of "Violence, Public Health, and the Media," by Gerteis, based on an Annenberg conference - one paragraph below
- If the media shape the public agenda, what shapes the media's agenda? McCombs argues that only about one-third of the stories in the mass media "thrust" themselves onto the agenda because of their objective importance to the public. Natural disasters or other public catastrophes, for example, fall into this category. The rest are there because they fit the conventions of journalism: they fill the need for drama, controversy, or human interest; they come from established and "reliable" sources; or they have been deemed worthy of coverage by The New York Times or The Washington Post. Equally important, the conventions of journalism--the choice of experts, the search for drama, "balance," or controversy--shape the way an issue is framed in the public mind. The mass media tell us not only what to think about, McCombs observes, but also how to think about it.
- Agenda Setting, includes discussion of which media (print or tv) has more impact on which segment of the public
Media Affecting Decision Making and Policy
- See CNN Effect section below and Agenda Setting section above
- War Policy, Public Support, and the Media (Local copy), by Darley, in Parameters, Summer 2005
- Impact of Public Perception on US National Policy: a Study of Media Influence in Military and Government Decision Making (Local copy), by Bly, at Naval Postgraduate School, 2002
- Decision Making and the Availability Heuristic - a self test of how publicity affects your reasoning
- Debunking the "Big O," by Siebert, in Track Two "a quarterly publication of the Centre for Conflict Resolution and the Media Peace Centre"
- "The news media shape our decisions and actions by informing and alerting us to what is going on in our communities as well as telling us about trends in our culture."
--- Congressional Testimony of Barry R. McCaffrey, 14 Oct 1999
- The Effects of Real-Time News Coverage on Military Decision-Making, by Adamson, ACSC, 1997
- The Impact of the Media on National Security Policy Decision Making (Local copy), by Johnson, at SSI, 1994
- Democracy and Protracted War: the Impact of Television, by Venanzi, in Air University Review, Jan-Feb 1983
Media and CNN Effect
- See agenda setting and decision-making sections above
- The CNN Effect: Strategic Enabler or Operational Risk? (Local copy), by Belknap, at US Army War College
- The Modern Media: The Impact on Foreign Policy (Local copy), by Hulme, at US Army Command and General Staff College
- The Impact of Media Information on Enemy Effectiveness: a Model for Conflict (local copy, 421 Kb), published in Proteus, used here by permission of the authors
- US Wars and the CNN Factor (local copy), by Brig. Gen. Mohammed Al-Allaf, National War College, 2001
- Winning CNN Wars (local copy), by Stech, in Parameters, Autumn 1994
- Air Power and the American Way of War (Local copy), speech by Gen Fogleman, including mention of CNN Effect
- Information System Components of Information Operations (Local copy), article in Military Review, Sep-Nov 1998, includes mention of CNN Effect
- The CNN Effect: TV and Foreign Policy, transcript of show featuring Peter Arnett, Marvin Kalb, Steve Livingston, and Admiral Kendell Pease
- Media vs. Military, transcript of show featuring Warren Strobel
- Review of book The News Media, Civil War and Humanitarian Action
- "Undeclared War: The Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict Reconsidered." in Journal of South Asian and Middle Eastern Studies, calls absence of the CNN Effect one of two reasons for low attention and aid
Media Ethics & Law
Media Watch
Crisis & Risk Communication
- See also same section on crisis communication on the Cyberspace and Info-Ops Study Center
- Health Risk Communication Program, from the US Army Center for Health Promotion and Preventive Medicine
- International Association for Public Participation (IAP2)
- Effective Risk Communication (80 pages) (Local copy), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Guidelines for External Risk Communication
- Effective Risk Communication - Quick Reference Guide (2 pages) (Local copy), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Guidelines for External Risk Communication
- Risk Communication Principles May Assist in Refinement of the Homeland Security Advisory System (Local copy), GAO report, Mar 2004
- Crisis and Emergency Risk Communication Course (CERC)
- Crisis and Emergency Risk Communication (CERC) (Local copy), handbook/course from CDC
- Psychology of a Crisis (Local copy, PDF file), briefing from CDC and DHHS (PPT file, much bigger)
- Seven Cardinal Rules of Risk Communication (Local copy), posted by CDC, from pamphlet drafted by Vincent T. Covello and Frederick H. Allen, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, April 1988, OPA-87-020
- Crisis Communication Spokesperson Checklist (Local copy), CDC
- A Primer on Health Risk Communication Principles and Practices (Local copy), Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, CDC -- includes many general tips on communication with the public
- Community Reaction to Bioterrorism: Prospective Study of Simulated Outbreak (Local copy), by DiGiovanni et al, in Emerging Infectious Diseases, June 2003 - "To assess community needs for public information during a bioterrorism-related crisis, we simulated an intentional Rift Valley fever outbreak in a community in the southern part of the United States."
- Communicating in a Crisis: Risk Communication Guidelines for Public Officials (Local copy), U.S. Dept of Health and Human Services
(Click here for HTML version)
- Risk Communication Primer (Local copy, 4 Mb), Navy Environmental Health Center - "a guide for conveying controversial or sensitive environmental, health, and safety information to a concerned audience" -- includes excellent tips on choosing delivery method, length of messages, language of messages, etc.
- Joint Information Center Model - Collaborative Communications During Emergency Response (Local copy), 21 Jan 2000, National Response Team
- Human Behavior and WMD Crisis / Risk Communication Workshop (Local copy), March 2001 report from DTRA, FBI, and US Joint Forces Command
- Crisis Communication - A Commanders Guide to Effective Crisis Communication (Local copy), Air University research paper -- with helpful guides and tips, especially in the appendices
- US Army Center for Health Promotion and Preventive Medicine
- Crisis Communication, OSD self-study online course, DINFOS
- Crisis Communication Plan - A Blue Print for Crisis Communication, Northern Illinois University
- Crisis Communications Guide & Toolkit, NEA
- Media Interaction with the Public in Emergency Situations: Four Case Studies (Local copy), Federal Research Division, Library of Congress -- Three Mile Island, Los Angeles Riots, World Trade Center Bombing, and Oklahoma City Bombing
- Communications and Crisis Actions, by Williams, in Air University Review, Mar-Apr 1978 - case study of the collapse of the South Vietnamese and Cambodian governments during the spring of 1975 and the joint crisis/contingency operations which resulted from the collapse
Media - Miscellaneous
- Military Justice and the Media: The Media Interview (Local copy), by Schwenk, posted by USAFA Department of Law - examines interviews, pretrial publicity, and related matters
- Public Relations in the Americas: Learning to Promote the Flow (Local copy), a panel discussion
- Military Reporters & Editors, the "Official Association of Military Journalists"
- Public Relations Society of America (PRSA)
- Risking more than their lives: Journalists and post-traumatic stress disorder, from Freedom Forum
- Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), with news and tips broken out by region of the world, including listings of dangerous assignments
- Project for Excellence in Journalism "an initiative by journalists concerned about the standards of the news media"
- Media History Project, including timeline from prehistory to now
[return to top]